A Constructivist Perspective on Leadership Thought among Brazilian and North-American Scholars
Journal Title: BAR: Brazilian Administration Review - Year 2011, Vol 8, Issue 2
Abstract
This paper presents the results of an exploratory, inductive cataloguing of the views of Brazilian and U.S. academics regarding current leadership theory and development. Semi structured interviews with academics from a variety of institutional settings in Brazil and the U.S. were content analyzed to identify major themes and tendencies across the two countries. Our analyses revealed that neither Brazilian nor U.S. academics adopted the bulk of current formal leadership thought uncritically. Instead, both the Brazilian and North American business education fields adopted theories selectively and formulated idiosyncratic approaches to the field. The U.S. interviewees appeared to vary much more from one another than the Brazilian scholars, whose positions were more critical but more homogeneous overall. There was also considerable variation across the two national settings. We found Bourdieu’s practice theory useful in interpreting our results, particularly the concepts of field differentiation and heteronomy, habitus, and cultural capital. Still, much research remains to be done to disentangle the purely historical and cultural factors from the impacts of the social construction of the field of business education in the two countries.
Authors and Affiliations
Sant'Anna, Anderson de Souza; Lotfi, Samir; Nelson, Reed Elliot; Campos, Marly Sorel; Leonel, Jordan Nassif
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP40492
- DOI -
- Views 273
- Downloads 0
Discretionary-Based Disclosure: Evidence from the Brazilian Market
The primary objective of this paper is to identify the factors that explain Brazilian companies‟ level of voluntary disclosure. Underpinning this work is the Discretionary-based Disclosure theory. The sample is composed...
Tourism Cluster Competitiveness and Sustainability: Proposal for a Systemic Model to Measure the Impact of Tourism on Local Development
This article proposes a model to measure tourism cluster impact on local development with a view to assessing tourism cluster interaction, competitiveness and sustainability impacts on the economy, society and the envi...
Determinants of Export Performance: a Study of Large Brazilian Manufacturing Firms
This research investigated the impact the external environment, firm characteristics and firm strategy have on export performance. To this end, a survey was administered to 448 large Brazilian exporters of manufactured...
Trust within Brazilian New Economy Organizations: an Empirical Investigation of Gender Effects Benchmarked on Brazilian Old Economy Organizations
It has been suggested that one of the negative aspects of the New Economy has been growing organizational survival-risk both at the firm and the sector levels. This precarious positioning of the firm has profoundly cha...
The Managerial Reduction in the Management Technologies Transposition Process to Public Organizations
This essay discusses the phenomenon of the implementation of technologies designed in the management business, with emphasis on relations with public organizations. It proposes a reflection on the concept of sociologic...