American Law, Global Norms: Th e Challenge of Enforcing Children with Disabilities’ Right to a Free and Appropriate Education
Journal Title: Białostockie Studia Prawnicze - Year 2018, Vol 0, Issue 23
Abstract
This essay critically analyzes the legal interpretation of the Supreme Court of the United States of what constitutes a “free and appropriate public education” for children with disabilities. Th rough the lens of a case study of an American child with communication disabilities, this essay examines why US law should instead be informed by a social model of disability embraced by the Convention of the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD). Related, the essay argues that American courts’ current interpretation of whether a student with disabilities has received an “appropriate education” relies too heavily on a medical model of disability, which requires a child fi rst to demonstrate suffi cient competence to merit related supports. Were the Supreme Court to adopt instead a social model of disability, however, it might advise public schools to presume the competence of students with disabilities. One implication of this essay is that even within the relatively robust legal framework for disability rights that presently exists in the US, judicial interpretation and enforcement of the law is too-oft en guided by judges’ ableist assumptions. For CRPD States Parties, the implication of this argument is that members of the judiciary should be trained not only in existing legal standards, but also in disability history and theory that can guide the interpretation of the legal standards. Th is essay critically analyzes the legal interpretation of the Supreme Court of the United States of what constitutes a “free and appropriate public education” for children with disabilities. Th rough the lens of a case study of an American child with communication disabilities, the essay examines why US law should instead be informed by a social model of disability embraced by the Convention of the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD). Related, the essay argues that American courts’ current interpretation of whether a student with disabilities has received an “appropriate education” relies too heavily on a medical model of disability, which requires a child fi rst to demonstrate suffi cient competence to merit related supports. Were the Supreme Court to adopt instead a social model of disability, however, it might advise public schools to presume the competence of students with disabilities. One implication of this essay is that even within the relatively robust legal framework for disability rights that presently exists in the US, judicial interpretation and enforcement of the law is too-oft en guided by judges’ ableist assumptions. For CRPD States Parties, the implication of this argument is that members of the judiciary should be trained not only in existing legal standards, but also in disability history and theory that can guide the interpretation of the legal standards. This brief essay proceeds in fi ve parts. The fi rst part sets forth a case study of a young American child’s attempts to secure an education despite his communication and physical disabilities. The second part sketches the legal framework, defi ning the standard for a “free and appropriate public education” in the United States. Th e third part elaborates the inherently illogical inconsistencies embedded in the current judicial standard in part by focusing on the case of pre-literate children with signifi cant communication disabilities. Th e fourth part argues that a social model of disability would invite schools to presume the competence of students with disabilities and off er them related supports. Th e fi ft h part unpacks an implication of this case study for States Parties to the CRPD. Ensuring access to a quality education for children with disabilities matters. For the 15% of the world’s population with disabilities, the issue implicates nothing less than the core of pluralist democracies’ claim to legally accommodate and realize the needs, preferences and rights of diverse individuals.
Authors and Affiliations
Cora True-Frost
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP514878
- DOI 10.15290/bsp.2018.23.04.08
- Views 54
- Downloads 0
The Right to Education for the Persons with Disabilities. Special View on the Romanian Legislation
The current study starts from the fact that the right to education – a fundamental human right – should be organized in such manner as to ensure equal opportunities for all persons. First of all, it refers to the prohibi...
Rodzina w systemie prawnym Szwajcarii. Kilka uwag o historii i rozwiązaniach współczesnych
In the article the historical determinants of the Swiss family status are presented. Th e patriarchal model, that had been practiced throughout the centuries, is described. Applying to the whole country, it had been perm...
Trwałość składu osobowego spółki cywilnej a wejście do spółki spadkobierców zmarłego wspólnika
Th e paper covers the concept of the sustainability of the composition of partners in a civil law partnership and, in this context, the entering of the deceased partner’s heirs into the partnership in that partner’s plac...
Dopuszczalność kasacji w sprawach o wykroczenia skarbowe
Th e article presents an analysis on the admissibility of cassation in tax misdemeanour cases in Poland. In such proceedings, the right of the parties to make a cassation was excluded and this privilege granted only to s...
Th e Limits of Autonomy of a Young Living Donor in Transplantation
Th e problem of legal regulation of ex vivo graft from a young living donor raises a lot of controversy. According to the Polish Act on the Collection, Preservation and Transplantation of Cells, Tissues and Organs, a mi...