Assessing stereotypes in medical professionals
Journal Title: Αρχεία Ελληνικής Ιατρικής - Year 2014, Vol 31, Issue 4
Abstract
Several types of methodological design have been used to assess the influence of stereotypes among doctors on various aspects of healthcare delivery. This review highlights the key findings and the shortcomings of the different methodological designs used to assess the impact of stereotypes on healthcare delivery, with an emphasis on medical decision-making. It is argued that while prospective, retrospective, and experimental methods of assessment have progressively established a valid and reliable link between stereotyping and healthcare outcomes, the methodology did not assess directly the presence of stereotypes, but assumed their existence from the differences in socio-demographic characteristics. Stereotypes, however, concern socially sensitive, implicit cognitive bias, and as such they can be neither overtly observed nor explicitly measured or manipulated. In addition, the relevant studies focused on broad and multi-factorial indicators of healthcare delivery (e.g., admission for surgery), while evidence regarding the impact of stereotypes on medical decision-making is very limited. It is further argued that despite evidence produced by the social and cognitive sciences that implicit assessment is the only reliable way to assess stereotypical thinking, a systematic approach to studying implicit bias in healthcare does not appear to have been taken. Based on current documentation, a shift away from the use of complex multifaceted indicators of healthcare towards a focus on medical decision-making is suggested, and specific lines of research are proposed, with the use of implicit measurements in stereotype assessment.
Authors and Affiliations
V. SPATOULA, E. PANAGOPOULOU, A. ALEXANDRIDI
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP157845
- DOI -
- Views 78
- Downloads 0
Εffect measure modification and confounding in applied medical research
The term "effect measure modification" was introduced by Miettinen and should be distinguished from the term "statistical interaction". The term "statistical interaction" is used to refer to a departure from the underlyi...
Εκτίμηση δύο ανοσοενζυμικών και μιας ανοσοχρωματογραφικής ταχείας μεθόδου <br /> για την ανίχνευση ειδικών αντιγόνων της Giardia lamblia <br /> στα κόπρανα ασθενών με λαμβλίαση <br /> <br />
ΣΚΟΠΟΣ Η εκτίμηση της ευαισθησίας και ειδικότητας δύο ανοσοενζυμικών μεθόδων (Alexon-Trend ProSpecT Giardia Microplate Assay και Cypress Diagnostics Giardiasis Ag ELISA) και μιας ανοσοχρωματογραφικής (Becton Dickinson Co...
Ghrelin: Existing knowledge and exciting prospects
The recent discovery of ghrelin led to new interesting developments in the study of the regulation of food intake. Ghrelin is a 28 amino acid peptide, which is mainly produced in the stomach. It is a powerful growth horm...
Primary antibody deficiencies in adults: A contemporary clinical approach
Primary antibody deficiencies (PADs) are no longer considered rare diseases. Given that about half of these disorders are diagnosed in adult life with a 5-year delay, while at death the median age of patients is above th...
Healthy dietary indices in public health practice and research
The scientific community has long been interested in the overall quality of diets owing to the fact that a healthy, varied and balanced diet is important for the health of each individual. Much research has been conducte...