Can analytical shading be art? Reflections on the canvas of experiments with ArcGIS and Surfer
Journal Title: Polish Cartographical Review - Year 2015, Vol 47, Issue 3
Abstract
Despite numerous theoretical and experimental studies of analytical relief shading, devised about half a century ago, its quality has not yet reached the excellence of traditional (manual) shading. The paper discusses its basic principles and the main factors affecting the quality of shading. It also stresses the crucial importance of the digital terrain model used as the basis for shading as well as the proper generalization of the relief. Experiments with shading modules of ArcGIS and Surfer, aiming to explore the functionality of algorithms they employ, have demonstrated significant similarity of the results. In conclusion, the authors attempt to answer the question posted in the title of the article. In their view, analytical shading is not art because shading algorithms are incapable of producing the visually beautiful effects that an experienced cartographer with artistic talents can create.
Authors and Affiliations
JERZY SIWEK SIWEK, WOJCIECH WACŁAWIK WACŁAWIK
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP366934
- DOI 10.1515/pcr-2015-0010
- Views 80
- Downloads 0
Polish adaptation of foreign geographical atlases for general use at the turn of the 20th and 21st centuries
Different approaches to the adaptation of foreign geographical atlases, making an effort of classification, against a background of the intensive activity of Polish publishers in the scope of adaptation of these atlases...
Cartographic generalization yesterday and today
The author presents evolution of views on cartographic generalization since it was defined by Emil von Sydow (1866) until today. It is divided into three chapters which present the evolution of views on cartographic gene...
Cartography of the Grand Duchy of Lithuania in the epoch of Jagiellonian rule
The author describes maps of the entire Grand Duchy of Lithuania, or its parts, created in the epoch of the Jagiellonian dynasty rule, i.e. in the years 1434–1572. The author also shows the role of local cartography of J...
Nowy wykaz polskich nazw geograficznych świata i zasady jego opracowania na tle dotychczasowych publikacji
Pod koniec 2013 roku wydany został „Urzędowy wykaz polskich nazw geograficznych świata” opracowany przez Komisję Standaryzacji Nazw Geograficznych poza Granicami Rzeczpospolitej Polskiej. Jest to drugi tego typu wykaz ob...
The problem of the availability of nautical charts and publications on the Northern Sea Route
Statistical studies of marine accidents and unfortunate events in ice-covered areas in 1995–2004 and 2004–2011 showed a general lack of information from the area under the jurisdiction of the Russian Federation. The auth...