Can Human Rights to Welfare Survive Without Religion?
Journal Title: The Journal of Human Rights - Year 2018, Vol 12, Issue 2
Abstract
Many contemporary authors fear that the proliferation of rights-claims may cause human rights to fall victim to their own popularity. If every good that is desired by one or another group of people is cloaked in the venerable garbs of a human right, and there is no way to tell ‘real’ from ‘supposed’ human rights, this may generate scepticism towards the concept of human rights in general. However deplorable this situation may be, for moral philosophers it may be thought to involve an opportunity to reaffirm the importance of their discipline. After all, how else could we distinguish genuine from imaginary human rights than by building a theory about the subject? The aim of my paper is to show that this idea is exactly wrong — that the proliferation of human rights claims cannot be stopped even in theory. It is a mistake to think that the proliferation of rights claims results from a lack of awareness of the proper theoretical foundation of human rights. On the contrary, I will argue that the proliferation of rights mirrors a deep problem in secular theories of human rights, that these theories do not have the conceptual resources to limit ever larger rights claims. I will suggest that to understand the present situation, we need to look into the religious presuppositions of the culture in which natural rights to subsistence were first proclaimed. Specifically, I will argue that contemporary theories of human rights are secularized versions of a religious precursor.
Authors and Affiliations
Siegfried Van Duffel
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP479161
- DOI 10.22096/HR.2018.92721.1064
- Views 114
- Downloads 0
Communal Dimension of the Right to Freedom of Religion
Right to freedom of religion is one of the fundamental human rights recognized in all general international human rights instruments. The basic standard which, with minor differences, is followed by subsequent instrument...
Minorities, Legal Autonomy Regimes and the Principle of Non-discrimination: A Comparative Study on the Conflict of Civil Codes and the Personal Laws of Minorities
In international human rights law the application of the principle of ‘equality’ along with the ‘preservation of characteristics’ have been considered as the corner stones of a system for the protection of minorities. Re...
Iranian-Islamic Identity: Discourse Analysis
Historically, the concept of "social identity" has a pivotal role in theories of social psychology and sociological theories. Postmodern perspective in particular characterizes identity as fluid and changing, because ide...
The Legal System of the Russian Federation Amid International Integration
International integration affects many sides of societal life, including the development of national legal systems. This article analyzes the regularities and algorithms of the mutual effect of national legal systems, w...
Opportunities and Challenges for the Engagement of Islamic Religious Leaders in Children’s Rights from the Perspective of UNICEF Iran
-