Conceptual Challenges to the Recognition and Enforcement of the Right to Clean, Safe and Healthy Environment
Journal Title: Journal of Environmental Law & Policy - Year 2022, Vol 2, Issue 02
Abstract
The right to clean or healthy environment, or what may be called environmental right, is one of the most controversial emerging rights since the agitation for the recognition of the link between human rights and the environment started gaining momentum at international law forums. This is happening partly because, at the global level, no treaty attempts to delimit the scope of this right explicitly; an endeavour which would have served as a form of guide to national jurisdictions. Given that the UN General Assembly recently officially resolved that a clean, healthy and sustainable environment is a universal human right, and considering the implication this may have on national jurisdictions, it has become more imperative to redefine this right for the ease of enforcement. This paper seeks to examine the conceptual and the theoretical conundrum as well as the criticisms of the right to clean, safe and healthy environment that have largely played a prominent role against the enforcement of the rights in general. The paper also examines constitutional challenges associated with the recognition of the rights in Nigeria and the judicial effort in the case of Gbemre v SPDC in attempting to expound the constitutional right to life to include the right to the environment. The paper finds that the right to the environment has been described and qualified diversely from one jurisdiction to another rendering the same susceptible to the challenges of interpretation. The paper, however, suggests that given the importance of the right, same should be interpreted, no matter how it is qualified, to mean a right to an environment fit for human living, the courts being sufficiently able to draw the line between what environment is fit and what is not for human habitation.
Authors and Affiliations
Brown Etareri Umukoro; Oghenerukevwe Ituru
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP716477
- DOI 10.33002/jelp02.02.01
- Views 68
- Downloads 0
Formation and Development of the Ecosystem Approach in International Environmental Law before the Convention on Biological Diversity
The article analyses general aspects of the formation and development of the ecosystem approach in international environmental law before the adoption and entry into force of the Convention on Biological Diversity. On th...
Environmental and Psychological Effects of Russian War in Ukraine
Russia invasion on Ukraine has extensive and unprecedented negative impacts on natural environment and human life. Since saving human lives and protecting nuclear establishments are a priority, the environmental destruct...
Allelopathic Responses of Crop Species to Chromolaena odorata Root Exudate Extracts: A Comprehensive Study
This study investigates the allelopathic effects of root exudate extracts from Chromolaena odorata on the germination and growth of six crop species. The results reveal variable sensitivity among the species, with the co...
A Critical Analysis of Legal Regime of Ship-Breaking and Ship-Recycling in Bangladesh
Shipbreaking and ship recycling is one of the major industries of Bangladesh. It is a significant contributor to Bangladesh’s economy and employment as well as one of the major sources of steel supply for the nation. How...
Assessment of Environmental Damage and Policy Actions by Using Contingent Valuation Method: An Empirical Analysis of Sago Industrial Pollution in Tamil Nadu, India
The objective of the study focusses on water quality, health impact, loss of agriculture production and livestock population. Primary data was collected from 413 households in the study villages of Kaveripuram, Ammampala...