Contingency Proof in the West
Journal Title: جستارهایی در فلسفه و کلام - Year 2009, Vol 41, Issue 82
Abstract
Contingency Proof is one of the oldest proofs of the existence of God, which enjoys numerous theological and philosophical expositions. What is examined in this article is the conventional form of this proof in the West, which has addressed the temporal contingency of universe and thereby demonstrated the existence of God. Its other expositions like essential contingency as well as substantial contingency, which are of special interest to Islamic philosophy, have either received no attention at all or not clearly stated. In this article, relying on the old and new scientific and theological sources of the West, the writer intends to reappraise and review this issue. Hereby, two rational proofs and two scientific arguments on its most significant premise have been presented. Its two rational proofs stress on the impossibility of actual infinite existence and the impossibility of addition to potential infinite and its transformation into actual infinite; and its two scientific arguments are adopted from the patterns of creation and thermodynamic principles. Bringing up various theories of the pros and cons among the philosophers and theologians, the article proceeds to present a critical review of the above issue.
Authors and Affiliations
Sayyid Murtaḍā ḤUsaynī ShāHrūDī
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP202461
- DOI 10.22067/philosophy.v41i1.3177
- Views 121
- Downloads 0
A Critical Look at Kant’s Ethics
Kant’s ethical theory is one the most important theories in philosophy of ethics, which has always attracted the attention of the commentators and critics. Although it has many positive points, there are some objections...
Examining the disagreement between Ibn Sina and Mulla Sadra on unity and the conceptual differences of divine names and attributes
The truth about Divine Names and the meanings of Divine Names and Attributes have always been regarded as key issues in Islamic theology and philosophy, and their surrounding debates have so far triggered controversial a...
Annihilation of Qualities from the Viewpoints of Mawlāna and Meister Eckhart
The existential and epistemological dimension of negative theology is based on two foundations in the works of the mystics from various religions and mystical traditions: God and the self (nafs). In the negative theology...
Critique of Mu’ayyid al-Dīn Jandī’s Theory on Ibn ‘Arabī’s being the Seal of the Saints of Allah (Khātam al-Awliyā)
One of the significant discourses of theoretical mysticism in Islam is the discussion about khātam al-awliyā (seal of the Saints). Mystics believe whatever exists in the world of being is a locus of manifestation for the...
Spiritual Sultanate of Imam al-Riḍā (A.S.) A Deliberation on the Conceptual Association between Divine Dominion and Calmness of the Heart in Ḥadīth of Imam al-Riḍā (A.S.)
“Spiritual Sultanate” is among the phrasings that Qāḍī Sa‘īd Qummī has used about Imamate. This concept has a direct relation with the Imam’s sovereignty in the world of Divine Commandment or malakūt (Divine Dominion). F...