Difficulties of Mental Mapping of Historical Time in the Chuvash National Identity: Cultural Continuities and Intellectual Failures
Journal Title: Social Evolution & History - Year 2017, Vol 16, Issue 1
Abstract
The concepts of historical time are among the focal points in the perception and invention of national history. The concepts and categories of historical time were actualized among non-historical nations when the latter became independent actors of historical process. The nationalists played a peculiar role in inventing the idea of historical time in general when they were fighting against their opponents from other formally dominating groups. The Chuvash concept of historical time was formed by the Chuvash nationalists while the first attempts to invent the Chuvash historical time took place between the two World Wars when the Chuvash nationalistically- oriented intellectuals tried to separate the category of the Chuvash historical time from the Russian collective representations of historical time. The Chuvash Soviet intellectuals of the second half of the twentieth century developed a loyal alternative of historical time integrated into a greater Soviet-Russian historical context. The collapse of the Soviet Union and fragmentation of the common historical space led to the disintegration of holistic historical time. The Chuvash intellectuals of the 1990s and the 2000s tried to revive a national idea of historical time of their predecessors from the interwar period. The intellectual community of historians in Chuvashia consists of two groups of historians who cultivate either a national Chuvash or a pro-Russian version of historical time. On the one hand, the general uncertainty of theChuvash historical time concept among intellectuals, on the one hand, stimulates the rise of historical pessimism. On the other hand, the historical situation in general has created a landscape for intellectual maneuvers. Therefore, the debates about historical time among the Chuvash nationalists still continue. The general trajectories of collective representations of transformations of historical time are still unclear.
Authors and Affiliations
Maksym W. Kyrchanoff
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP265912
- DOI -
- Views 140
- Downloads 0
The Settlement of a Region as a Historical Phenomenon: The Middle Volga and Transvolga Regions in the Development of the Russian Civilization and Nation
A review of Kabytov, P. S., Dubman E. L., and Leontieva, O. B. (Eds.) ‘Finding Homeland’: Society and Power in the Middle Volga Region (from the Second Half of the 16th to Early 20th Centuries). Vol. 2. Regional Settleme...
International Conference of Africanists “Africa and Africans in National, Regional and Global Dimensions”
On 17–20 October 2017, the Institute for African Studies of the Russian Academy of Sciences hosted the 14th African Studies Conference ‘Africa and Africans in National, Regional and Global Dimensions’. In line with the l...
Optimization Theories of the Transition from Foraging to Agriculture: A Critical Assessment and Proposed Alternatives
es, one in economics and the other in anthropology, explain the economic evolution of Neolithic societies, particularly their transit from foraging to agriculture. Both assume rational optimizing behavior. It is argued t...
Spiritism, Violence, and Social Struggle in Late Nineteenth-Century Catalonia
This article discusses different situations concerning the positioning of the nineteenth-century Catalan spiritism towards violence: on the one hand, with regard to capitalist's society's implementation of the industrial...
The Wameru of Tanzania: Historical Origin and Their Role in the Process of National Integration
The Meru live in one of the most fertile and densely populated areas of Tanzania, and their current population number is about 198,000 peo- ple. Today they are organized in 26 clans. Most Wameru claim their origin from t...