Does Film Keep Anti-psychiatry Alive? Aesthetic Knowledge of Mental Illness and Institutions
Journal Title: Res Rhetorica - Year 2015, Vol 2, Issue 4
Abstract
The paper aims at evaluating contemporary films on psychiatry and their ‘knowledge’ of mental illness: How are mental illness and psychiatric institutions characterized rhetorically, and, are some psychiatric theories more present than others in the epistemological development of the fi lms? I will argue that the film ‘One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest’ (1975) by Milos Forman has an iconic status. It was based on a novel by Ken Kesey from 1961 and can be related to anti-psychiatry – a political movement as well as a psychiatric theory infl uenced by social constructivism, e.g. Michel Foucault. In The Divided Self (1960) by Ronald D. Laing and The Myth of Mental Illness (1962) by Thomas Szasz conventional psychiatric language was deconstructed. Thus, Szasz pleaded that mental illness did not exist and built up a new effective antipsychiatric language characterized by metaphors such as ‘prison’ and ‘prisoner’. These metaphors were given both presence (Perelman) and evidentia by Forman, who focused on clanking keys, bars, and belt fixation in the introduction to ‘One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest’. Also contemporary movies dealing with psychiatry, such as ‘Girl Interrupted’ (1999) by James Mangold, use the prison as a metaphor, probably as an intertextual reference to Forman’s film. In the end of the paper I will discuss the effect of these movies. Do they keep anti-psychiatry alive in the 21th century – even when the psychiatric theory as well as the political movement have lost influence?
Authors and Affiliations
Jette Barnholdt Hansen
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP192125
- DOI 10.17380/rr2015.4.3
- Views 119
- Downloads 0
The Concept of ‘Rhetoric’ in a Linguistic Perspective: Historical, Systematic, and Theoretical Aspects of Rhetoric as Formal Language Usage
Rhetoric is commonly known as an old discipline for the persuasive usage of language in linguistic communication acts. In this article we examine the concept ‘rhetoric’ from 1. the diachronic perspective of historical li...
Między chaosem a porządkiem – retoryczne zmagania z wybuchem I wojny światowej na łamach „Tygodnika Ilustrowanego”
Analiza tekstów opublikowanych w latach 1913-1914 (przed wybuchem I wojny światowej) w „Tygodniku Ilustrowanym” wskazuje, iż wydawane w Warszawie pismo koncentrowało swoją uwagę przed wszystkim na zachowaniu rozwagi i dy...
Retoryka prezydenta Richarda Nixona wobec kryzysu naftowego w 1973
Niniejszy artykuł przedstawia analizę retoryki prezydenta Richarda Nixona wobec kryzysu naftowego na przykładzie orędzia do narodu wygłoszonego 7 listopada 1973 roku. W ramach określonych przez Theodore’a Otto Windta, Jr...
Framing violent conflicts on the official Amnesty International Facebook page
The article's main purpose is to show how the News Framing Theory operates within the news about violent conflicts presented by the journalists working for the Amnesty International organization. It tries to identify fra...
Science and the Religious Rhetorics of the Ineffable: A Comparison Between Two Cosmoses
Since Thomas Kuhn’s revolutionary look at the social construction of science, research into the rhetorics of science has shown how science is a persuasive form of discourse, rarely as transparent and self-evident as is o...