Étienne Gilson, Duns Scotus, and Actual Existence: Weighing the Charge of ‘Essentialism’
Journal Title: Studia Gilsoniana - Year 2017, Vol 6, Issue 3
Abstract
Étienne Gilson juxtaposes what he calls Aquinas’s “existentialism” to what he calls Scotus’s “essentialism.” For Gilson, “existentialism” is philosophical truth, the only view compatible with an authentically Christian metaphysic, while “essentialism” is a Hellenic mistake that seduces Christian philosophers by appealing to the idolatrous desire to reduce reality to what is intelligible. In this paper, the author attempts to describe the difference between “essentialism” and “existentialism” as understood by Gilson. Then, he assesses the case for attributing “essentialism” to Scotus, based on an assessment of Scotus texts and secondary scholarship.
Authors and Affiliations
Andrew C. Helms
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP252066
- DOI -
- Views 241
- Downloads 0
The Hidden God. Achilles, Aquinas, and Moral Action in an Ordered World
The central goals of this essay are three: (1) to situate St. Thomas’s moral psychology within his cosmology, with special emphasis on the notion of virtual quantity; (2) to illuminate and confirm that moral psychology t...
ST. THOMAS AQUINAS, DRAMATIST?
The article begins with the statement that there is one aspect of St Thomas’s work that has not received due scrutiny as a literary form, one with solid dramatic qualities and structure: the Article. The Article is as Th...
GILSON ON THE RATIONALITY OF CHRISTIAN BELIEF
The underlying skepticism of ancient Greek culture made it unreceptive of philosophy. It was the Catholic Church that embraced philosophy. Still, Étienne Gilson reminds us in Reason and Revelation in the Middle Ages that...
Classical Metaphysics and Theistic Evolution: Why Are They Incompatible?
This paper explores the arguments against the compatibility of classical metaphysics (Aristotelian-Thomistic) and theistic evolution. It begins with presenting the line of division between theists and atheistic evolution...
MARITAIN AND AQUINAS ON OUR DISCOVERY OF BEING
The author presents and compares Maritain’s and Aquinas’s accounts of our discovery (1) of being as existing; and (2) of being as being (ens inquantum ens or the subject of metaphysics). He finds that especially in his f...