Functional and radiological outcome in non-operative versus operative management of fracture clavicle
Journal Title: International Archives of Integrated Medicine - Year 2016, Vol 3, Issue 3
Abstract
Background: Clavicle fractures are one of the most common bone injuries seen in adult population. Generally all the fracture clavicles were treated non-surgically by figure-eight bandage and surgical intervention like plating with cortical screws is infrequently required. Non-union rates, strength and endurance deficits are familiar in cases treated conservatively. We evaluated functional and radiological outcomes in non operative versus operative management of fracture clavicle, in patients visiting to orthopedic OPD in a tertiary care hospital in Andhra Pradesh. Material and methods: In a prospective clinical trial study of 80 patients, with displaced mid-shaft fractures of the clavicle were referred to Orthopedic OPD in a tertiary care hospital. These patients were deliberately placed into two treatment groups: non-surgical (with figure-eight bandage) and surgical (with DCR plate fixation). All patients of the surgical group underwent ORIF. Clinical examination, fracture radiography and shoulder scores were recorded for all patients at the end of 12 weeks. Shoulder function is measured by the constant shoulder score which includes the pain score, functional assessment, range of motion and strength measures. Patient satisfaction according to strength, shoulder function and pain was also assessed. Results: There were 32 patients in operative in which 23 males and 9 females whereas in non-operative group (figure of eight) there were 35 males and 13 females. The mean age of the patient was 23±3.4 years in operative and 19±2.5 years in non-operative group. 61 fractures occurred on the right side and 10 on the left side. In the Surgical group mean time to reunion was 8±1.8 weeks where as it was 11.±2 weeks in non surgical group. The overall Constant shoulder score was 93.75% in surgical group where as it was 87.50% in nonsurgical group. Additionally the percentage of patients with excellent results was more in surgical group than non- operative group (figure of eight). Conclusion: In both figure of eight bandage and plating, there was satisfactory union of clavicle but due to appropriate bone proximity in cortical screw and plating, excellent functional outcome in the terms of early mobilization and quick union was much appreciated.
Authors and Affiliations
Koramutla Harsha Kumar, Jaya Someswar Narreddy
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP418312
- DOI -
- Views 111
- Downloads 0
A lipid profile study amongst the patients of type 2 diabetes mellitus - A cross sectional study
Introduction: India leads the world with largest number of diabetic patients and is often referred to as the diabetes capital. Diabetic dyslipidemia in India is one of the main causes for Coronary Artery Disease (CAD) mo...
Abdominal trauma – A clinical study
Introduction: Trauma increase in incidence may be the price marking paying for the increased sophistication of industrialization and various paying for the increased sophistication of industrialization and various rapid...
Evaluation of hs-CRP levels in acute coronary syndromes
Background: The incidents of CAD is increasing alarmingly and evidence is emerging about the role of novel risk factors. hs-CRP is emerging as a crucial risk factor for premature atherothrombosis and cardio vascular even...
Ovarian tumors - Incidence and histopathological spectrum in tertiary care center, Valsad
Introduction: Ovarian tumors are now the one of the leading cause of death involving a wide spectrum of clinical, morphological and histopathological diagnosis. It frequently does not result in symptoms until the tumor h...
Blistering mucocutaneous disease of oral cavity Pemphigus vulgaris – 8 year study in Nalgonda population
Background: Autoimmune disorders are conditions in which autoantibodies are directed against a single organ or tissue resulting in localized tissue damage. Pemphigus includes a group of autoimmune blistering diseases of...