FUTURE OF TAX EXEMPTIONS FOR CHURCHES IN THE LIGHT OF THE RECENT UNITED STATES SUPREME COURT DECISIONS
Journal Title: Studia z Prawa Wyznaniowego - Year 2013, Vol 16, Issue 16
Abstract
For many years, the United States Supreme Court (SC) decisions in the field of tax exemptions for churches have remained unchanged. Still, their constitutional future is not clear. The main reason behind that is development of LGBT rights, guaranteed by the Equal Protection and Due Process Clauses of the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments to the US Constitution. The recent SC decisions in Christian Legal Society Chapter v. Martinez from 2010, Hosanna-Tabor Evangelical Lutheran Church and School v. EEOC from 2012, and United States v. Windsor from 2013, show us the most possible directions in which the SC would enter into growing conflict between a full homosexual equality and religious freedom, guaranteed by the Free Exercise and Establishment Clause of the First Amendment to the US Constitution. According to the author, after the SC decisions in Martinez and Windsor it seems quite obvious that “homophobic” churches would have lost their tax exempt status under the provisions of Bob Jones University v. United States and Employment Division v. Smith. From the other hand – if only same-sex marriage would not have become universal in the USA – the unanimous decision in Hosanna-Tabor would have got “homophobic” churches out of the operation of Smith, in order to prevent them from abandoning their discriminatory tenets.
Authors and Affiliations
Piotr Michalik
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP93902
- DOI -
- Views 217
- Downloads 0
PROWADZENIE DZIAŁALNOŚCI GOSPODARCZEJ NA CMENTARZACH WYZNANIOWYCH PRZEZ OSOBY PRAWNE KOŚCIOŁA KATOLICKIEGO
Prawodawstwo Rzeczypospolitej Polskiej zapewnia kościołom i innym związkom wyznaniowym prawo posiadania, zarządzania oraz zakładania i poszerzania cmentarzy grzebalnych przy zachowaniu przepisów dotyczących cmentarzy i c...
Prawo pacjenta do opieki duszpasterskiej w świetle konstytucyjnej zasady równouprawnienia kościołów i innych związków wyznaniowych
Przedmiotem artykułu jest przedstawienie prawa pacjenta do opieki duszpasterskiej w perspektywie problematyki położenia prawnego wspólnoty religijnej, której wyznawcą lub członkiem pozostaje pacjent. Analiza uwzględnia z...
KINDERGARTENS AND NURSERIES IN THE LIGHT OF EDUCATION LAW IN POLAND BETWEEN 1945 AND 1961
Polish communist authorities of the People's Republic sought to secularization of education system, starting from the lowest level of education, namely kindergartens. As part of the anti-Church state religious policy, ki...
PARLIAMENTARY WORK OF THE 1919–1922 LEGISLATIVE SEJM ON THE VINDICATION OF THE CHURCH ESTATES CONFISCATED BY TSARISM
After the January Uprising, Polish society, especially the Polish Church and the clergy, fell victim to repression by the government of tsarist Russia. Clergymen in large numbers were sentenced to death or deported to Si...
Rec. Henryk Ryszard Tomaszewski, Baptyści w Polsce w latach 1918-1958, Warszawa 2008, ss. 516