Gibson’s ecological approach – a model for the benefits of a theory driven psychology
Journal Title: AVANT. Pismo awangardy filozoficzno-naukowej - Year 2012, Vol 0, Issue 2
Abstract
Unlike most other sciences, psychology has no true core theory to guide a coherent research programme. It does have James J Gibson’s ecological approach to visual perception, however, which we suggest should serve as an example of the benefits a good theory brings to psychological research. Here we focus on an example of how the ecological approach has served as a guide to discovery, shaping and constraining a recent hypothesis about how humans perform coordinated rhythmic movements (Bingham 2004a, b). Early experiments on this task were framed in a dynamic pattern approach. This phenomenological, behavioural framework (e.g. Jeka & Kelso 1989) classifies the behaviour of complex action systems in terms of the key order parameters, and describes the dynamical stability of the system as it responds to perturbations. Dynamical systems, however, while a valuable toolkit, is not a theory of behaviour, and this style of research is unable to successfully predict data it is not explicitly designed to fit. More recent work by Bingham & colleagues has used dynamical systems to formalise hypotheses derived from Gibson’s ecological approach to perception and action, with a particular emphasis on perceptual information. The resulting model (Bingham 2001, 2004a, b; Snapp-Childs et al. 2011) has had great success with both the phenomena it was designed to explain as well as a wide range of empirical results from a version of the task it is not specifically designed to explain (specifically, learning a novel coordination). This model and the research programme that produced it stand as an example of the value of theory driven research, and we use it to illustrate the contemporary importance the ecological approach has for psychology.
Authors and Affiliations
Sabrina Golonka, Andrew Wilson
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP114704
- DOI -
- Views 78
- Downloads 0
Phenomenology and the project of naturalization
In recent years more and more people have started talking about the necessity of reconciliating phenomenology with the project of naturalization. Is it possible to bridge the gap between phenomenological analyses and nat...
Our tender Middle Ages. Interview with Patrizia Bovi
Stara dobra etnografia laboratorium
'Handling Digital Brains' udowadnia, że etnografia laboratorium wciąż może wnosić istotny wkład w dziedzinie społecznych studiów nad nauką i technologią. Recenzowana praca prezentuje szczegóły interakcji między badaczami...
Co ze mną zrobisz, kiedy mnie zobaczysz? Percepcja jako wyszukiwanie ofert (affordances) w otoczeniu
Współczesne próby łączenia percepcji z działaniem czerpią z Gibsonowskiej koncepcji ofert (affordances). Tekst szkicuje pojęciowe podstawy tej koncepcji pokazując, jak pojęcie oferty wpisuje się w teorię percepcji, rozum...
Varieties of Presence. A book review