Is A Gender Analysis of Social Policy Still Required in High Income Countries? A Case Study of The New Zealand Sole Parent Benefit; Objectives and Outcomes
Journal Title: Journal of Advanced Research in Social Sciences - Year 2019, Vol 2, Issue 3
Abstract
New Zealand is considered an egalitarian society, with a progressive policy history in promoting gender equality, however, this paper illustrates how social policy does not always support this agenda. The objective of New Zealand Sole Parent Benefit is to provide temporal financial support to sole parents and their dependents while supporting a transition into formal paid employment. While ultimately aimed at increasing the labour force participation of sole parents, this paper queries to what extent the policy has achieved this objective and why. Recipient statistics are disaggregated by gender to highlight the disproportionate impact on, and unequal outcomes for women. Furthermore, a gendered analysis informed by feminist economists Naileer Kabeer, Diane Elson and Nancy Folbre, alongside statistical evidence of a gender pay gap, occupational segregation and motherhood penalty is applied to demonstrate how market constraints affect New Zealand women’s participation in the labour force, and contribute to the counter intuitive policy results. While these factors do not account for individual differences in motivation, nor individual aspirations, unless the gendered nature of the labour market is addressed, women will continue to face higher rates of engagement on the Sole Parent Benefit and continue to experience disproportionate economic disadvantage and financial insecurity. The consistent use of a gendered analysis in policy design and implementation is essential to reduce gender-based disadvantage, even in countries believed to promote gender equality.
Authors and Affiliations
Katheryn Margaret Pascoe
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP743716
- DOI https://doi.org/10.33422/jarss.v2i3.228
- Views 47
- Downloads 0
The Profile of the Romanian Voter in European Elections
A European voter is a person who has their own political, social, and cultural background, while sharing a main goal with other Europeans: preserving democracy and the values and benefits that it entails. With more than...
Analysing How the Shift in Discourses on Social Media Affected the Narrative Around the Indian General Election 2019
The Lok Sabha Elections 2019 in the worldâs largest democracy, India, was the biggest electoral event on the planet. These elections are key in the selection of the Prime Minister, the highest authority in the cabinet....
The Nature-Nurture Controversy: The Nucleo-genre Paradigm as a Means of Understanding Gender
The relation between the sexes has long been founded on the basis of masculine domination. Interpreting biological differences as evidence of male superiority, social institutions - the family, religious and educational...
A Narrative Approach to Understanding the Development of Cultural Intelligence Among Migrant Domestic Workers
Filipino migrants all over the world naturally engage in encounters that necessitate the use of cultural intelligence (CQ) or the ability to interact effectively with people who are culturally different. Studies have sho...
A Folklorist Extraordinaire: Pertev Naili Boratav, a Pioneer in Turkish Folklore Studies
Born in 1907 in Istanbul, Boratav's journey into the realm of folklore studies began at an early age, as he was deeply fascinated by the cultural narratives, customs, and beliefs that permeated Turkish society. After com...