Jakich hipotez nie stawiał Isaac Newton?

Abstract

Logical empiricists, Popper and Lakatos claimed that making science consists in inventing and verifying hypotheses and theories. The process of inventing hypotheses was to remain outside the reach of logical analysis. Procedures of empirical testing, which resulted in taking the rational decision to accept or reject or modify a hypothesis were to be logically reconstructed. Contrary to the image Isaac Newton argued that hypotheses „have no place in [science]. In [science] particular propositions are inferred from the phaenomena, and afterwords rendered general by induction. Thus it was that […] the laws of motion and of gravitation were discovered” (1713). From the standpoint of Ludwik Fleck’s theory of thought collectives and thought styles, Newton was wrong, but not quite. The law of gravity was in fact deduced, and the process of deduction can be logically reconstructed. But Newton’s premisses were not phenomena alone: these were sentences describing the phenomena and active assumptions of the thought style that Newton – not being aware of it – inherited from the thought collective he belonged to.

Authors and Affiliations

Wojciech Sady

Keywords

Related Articles

Bioetyka – krótka lekcja historii

Recenzja pracy: Ferber, "Bioethics in Historical Perspective", Basingstoke 2013.

Idee oraz wierzenia. Antropologiczno-epistemologiczna aktualność poglądów José Ortegi y Gasseta

Podstawowym celem artykułu jest prezentacja funkcji wierzeń oraz idei w pracach Ortegi y Gasseta. Wierzenia i idee powstają jako konieczna odpowiedź na enigmatyczność otoczenia, w jakim żyje podmiot, stanowiąc warunek is...

Drobne gospodarstwa i ich właściciele na polskiej wsi. Refleksje socjologiczne

The agrarian structure of today’s Poland is dominated by small farms. There is no precise defintion of what “small” means in this case, but it is estimated that such entities account for 40%–65% of the total number of fa...

Participatory Democracy and the Disadvantaged Factors: The Taiwan and Czech Republic Cases

Paper focuses on civic participation and its disadvantaged factors in civil society and demo¬cratic life in new democracies, especially after long-term deprivation of political freedom. I emphasize the experiences of Cen...

„Telechata” jako instrument zrównoważonego rozwoju obszarów wiejskich

The subject matter of the article is the Telecottage, that is the public access point to information technologies (IT) offered to rural populations. On the one hand, the author focuses on the description on this new and...

Download PDF file
  • EP ID EP71841
  • DOI -
  • Views 88
  • Downloads 0

How To Cite

Wojciech Sady (2010). Jakich hipotez nie stawiał Isaac Newton?. Annales Universitatis Mariae Curie-Sklodowska, Sectio I Philosophia-Sociologia, 35(2), 65-84. https://europub.co.uk./articles/-A-71841