Kontrola konstytucyjności ustaw przez sądy arbitrażowe – perspektywa polska i międzynarodowa
Journal Title: ADR. Arbitraż i Mediacja - Year 2016, Vol 3, Issue 35
Abstract
Verification of constitutionality of laws by arbitral tribunals – a polish and international perspective This article discusses the issue of the arbitral tribunals’ authority to disregard purportedly applicable statutory provisions of a given national law which it deems to be non-compliant with relevant constitutional norms, both from the perspective of the Polish constitutional and arbitration law, as well as the international arbitration jurisprudence. Due to the fact that in recent years, unlike in the Polish scholarship, the issue at hand has attracted considerable attention in international academia, the paper begins its analysis by reporting various positions adopted by some of the leading international scholars on the matter in question. This initial study provides a firm base for further exploration of this issue in the light of the Polish law. Such critical analysis drives the author to a conclusion that there are no sufficiently persuasive arguments which would justify baring international arbitrators from applying the Polish substantive law in its entirety, including denying the application of provisions violating the Constitution which shall supersede other normative acts. Conversely, the exercise of such arbitration process amounts to a basic duty of arbitrators (integral part of their mandate to resolve a dispute in accordance with the Polish law as the applicable substantive law of a dispute) rather than their discretionary authority.
Authors and Affiliations
Andrzej Olaś
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP181911
- DOI -
- Views 48
- Downloads 0
Bibliografia kwartalnika ADR za lata 2015(4)–2018(3)
Bibliografia kwartalnika ADR za lata 2015(4)–2018(3).
Wpływ klauzuli integralności (merger) na zapis na sąd polubowny
This paper addresses the question whether the so called integration clause should influence the binding effect of the arbitration clause. An integration clause is a provision in a written contract stating that the contra...
Związanie członka zarządu spółki z o.o. zapisem na sąd polubowny w procesie o naprawienie szkody na podstawie art. 293 KSH
The publication describes the possibility of binding a board member to the arbitration clause in the articles of association of a limited liability company during the process arising on the basis of article 293 of Polish...
Zasada dobrowolności mediacji w świetle nowelizacji Kodeksu postępowania cywilnego z 10.9.2015 r.
The article “The principle of voluntariness of mediation in the light of the amendment to the Code of Civil Procedure of 10th of September 2015” discusses legal issues regarding the current regulations that modified the...
Charakterystyka prawnoporównawcza instytucji arbitra doraźnego w wybranych regulaminach stałych sądów arbitrażowych
The aim of this paper is to make a comparative legal analysis of the institution of an emergency arbitrator in the chosen arbitration rules made by the biggest permanent arbitration courts. An emergency arbitrator enable...