Legal and Juridical Study of Qiṣāṣ through Donation of Organs
Journal Title: فقه و اصول - Year 2012, Vol 44, Issue 90
Abstract
The applicability of executing the qiṣāṣ punishment through donation of organs is a novel topic and at the same time influential in safeguarding the blessings of human health and life. The legitimacy of this procedure requires delving into legal views and opinions. The renowned majority of Imāmī jurists believe that the procedure of executing punishment in blood-vengeance has no topicality (relevance), and punishment has to be executed in a way that inflicts the least suffering on the criminal. In contrast, some other jurists believe that the equality and resemblance (mumāthilat) between the quality and procedure of executing the punishment and the perpetrated crime is an essential condition. According to this group of jurists, upon committing a murder, the whole body of the murderer is made available to the legal guardians (avengers of blood), who have carte blanche in executing blood vengeance in proportion to the features of the perpetrated crime. Accepting the above-mentioned approach, the necessity of resemblance in the quality of punishment and the perpetrated crime is no longer an option and the blood vengeance can be administered using methods that inflict the least pain and suffering on the criminal. It is for this reason that the renowned majority of Imāmī jurists have on one hand emphasized on administration of blood vengeance with a sharp sword and on the other hand have accepted using the new methods that conform to the criteria presented above. Therefore, it seems that the procedure of donation of organ can also be used in administration of blood vengeance.
Authors and Affiliations
‘Abd Al-Riḍā JavāN Ja‘Farī, Sayyid MuḥAmmad JavāD SāDāTī
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP183781
- DOI 10.22067/fiqh.v0i0.7427
- Views 130
- Downloads 0
Collective beneficence (collective good) an its role in civil liability
Beneficence as a principle is one of the definite jurisprudential rules and a disclaimer of civil liability of the individual in terms of the loss enforced upon others during acts of collective good. This shall necessita...
Legal and Juridical Study of Qiṣāṣ through Donation of Organs
The applicability of executing the qiṣāṣ punishment through donation of organs is a novel topic and at the same time influential in safeguarding the blessings of human health and life. The legitimacy of this procedure re...
Examining the Legal Principles of the Ruling on the Retaliated Punishment (Qiṣāṣ) of Mother for Murdering her Child
Murder is among the most abominable human acts and the most criminal behavior of mankind; in Shī’a jurisprudence, punishment for deliberate murder is qiṣāṣ (retaliated punishment) in general. On the basis of this general...
A critical view of ‘the necessity of imprisonment of the insolvent in paying the dower’
The dower is the first financial debt which established incumbent upon the husband after the realization of marriage. The wife has the right to demand the debt from the husband and then obtain its possession. If after th...
The nature of signed ordinances
Signed ordinances are a major part of religious ordinances having existed as normative before the institution of divine canonization and having been approved without any or with slight modification by the legislator and...