Love your neighbor as yourself! Tolstoy versus Petrazycki on the social significance of law and morality
Journal Title: Krytyka Prawa. Niezależne studia nad prawem - Year 2014, Vol 6, Issue 1
Abstract
The article is a polemic between Leo Tolstoy, a famous Russian writer and moralist of the nineteenth century, and Leon Petrażycki, a lawyer and a philosopher of law of that period, the then professor at the University of St. Petersburg, later a lecturer at the University of Warsaw – on the social significance of law and morality. Tolstoy's and Petrażycki's roads crossed due to a young man named Krutik, a law student at the University of St. Petersburg. Krutik wrote a letter to Tolstoy, whom he considered a moral authority, asking to dispel his doubts caused by reading the works of Petrażycki. Indeed, Tolstoy affirmed that the only appropriate regulator of human life is morality. In contrast, Petrażycki proclaimed that the raison d'être has both morality and law, but if one compares their social significance, the higher value should be given to the law. Krutik had a dilemma, which thinker to agree.Analysis of Tolstoy's and Petrażycki's views made in this article leads to the conclusion that in fact they were arguing about how to implement the idea of love, somewhat differently interpreted by them. While Tolstoy categorically rules out the possibility of realizing it on legal grounds, Petrażycki was firmly convinced that the law can absolutely be its carrier.
Authors and Affiliations
Katarzyna Tynkiewicz
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP62481
- DOI -
- Views 100
- Downloads 0
The competences of the National Judicial Council and their impact on the realisation of the independence of Judges and the independence of courts. Prolegomena
The article presents the powers of the National Council of the Judiciary of Poland in terms of their potential impact on the implementation of the principle of the independence of judges and independence of courts. Durin...
[b]Refusal to Deal as an Abuse of Dominant Position[/b]
As a rule companies are free to decide where and when they will sell their products and with which companies or clients they are prepared to contract. Such freedom is not unlimited and a dominant company which refuses to...
Istota danin publicznych stanowiących dochód budżetu gminy na tle zadań realizowanych przez samorząd gminy – wybrane zagadnienia prawne
W niniejszym artykule analizie zostanie poddana sytuacja prawno-finansowa samorządu gminy w odniesieniu do rodzajów i istoty dochodów gminy na tle zadań wykonywanych przez samorząd gminy. Samorząd gminy realizuje zadania...
Suitable application of the provisions of the Code of Administrative Procedure in matters of decisions issued by the university authorities on the basis of the provisions of the Act – Law on Higher Education
The theme of the article is suitable application of the provisions of the Code of Administrative Procedure in cases where a decision is issued by universities. The article discusses the case law of administrative courts...
Znaczenie opinii biegłego w procesach medycznych w świetle orzecznictwa polskich sądów
Zasadniczą przeszkodą w sprawnym prowadzeniu spraw medycznych, wymagającą szczególnego podkreślenia, są olbrzymie trudności sądów w przeprowadzaniu dowodu z opinii biegłych w rozsądnym terminie. Dowód ten jest w zasadzie...