Metafizyczna reinterpretacja sakramentu Eucharystii w polemice ze św. Tomaszem z Akwinu na gruncie art. 6 zagadnienia 78 Traktatu o Eucharystii jego Sumy teologicznej
Journal Title: Wrocławski Przegląd Teologiczny - Year 2015, Vol 0, Issue 1
Abstract
Criticism against St. Thomas Aquinas — intentionally emulating the scholastic method of proving — regards the effect of the forms of consecrat- ing the bread and wine during the Eucharist. This reveals an absurd prob- lem — encountered by Aquinas in his Summa Theologica — rooted in the confusion between different concepts and connotations attached to the term “Eucharist” while trying to accommodate them and explain in one of those connotations, i.e., “the sacrament of the Eucharist”. Apparently, the solution can be provided by isolating, among other things, a second term: “liturgy of the sacrament of the Eucharist”, and critically revising all that makes mat- ter and form of “the sacrament of the Eucharist” itself. The conclusions of criticism suggest that it is rational to transfer the search for the moment of transubstantiation from the so-called words of consecration to the epiclesis. Finally, it is time to indicate that on 20 July 2001, the Pontifi cal Council for Promoting Christian Unity recognized the complete validity of the Anaphora of Addai and Mari, without the words of consecration, thus practically con- fi rming by the Catholic Church that this direction of theological endeavours is right.
Authors and Affiliations
Krzysztof Suszko
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP195819
- DOI -
- Views 60
- Downloads 0
Jewish Anti-Christian Polemical Treatises in Early Modern Central and Eastern Europe: Where are They?
Jewish anti-Christian polemical treatises comprise a well-known genre in medieval Jewish literature. It is generally thought that these books were written in response to Christian missionary pressure. Yet, when consideri...
W cieniu jabłoni i rozpadlinach skały. Semiotyczna lektura Pnp 2, 3 i 2, 14
This article is an analysis of the two units of the Song of Songs 2:3 and 2:14 that show the importance of a conscious choice of the Bridegroom and the Bride in shaping the relationship of love. Motives present in them,...
Rola Jana Muskaty, archidiakona łęczyckiego, w wielkim sporze biskupa Tomasza II z Henrykiem IV Probusem
The Middle Ages in Silesia is a time of great dispute between the bish- op and the prince, church – political and legal disputes, which liberated the church from the power of the prince. One of these disputes was between...
Nowe życie w Chrystusie w nowej ewangelizacji w mediach
More than three billion internet users in the world (42 per cent of human population), nearly 26 million users in Poland (67% of the country popula- tion), together with nearly 1.5 billion Facebook users in the world and...
Filozoficzno-egzystencjalna anatomia choroby, cierpienia i śmierci
Despite the fact that there exists a substantial amount of scientific works dedicated to various aspects of illness, suffering, dying and death – all the research still appears to be incomplete. Very often they offer onl...