Нормативно-правовий зміст доступу до суду та обов’язковості судових рішень як засади кримінального провадження / Normative and Legal Content of Access to Court and a Binding Nature of a Court Decisions as Principles of Criminal Proceedings
Journal Title: Журнал східноєвропейського права - Year 2018, Vol 51, Issue
Abstract
The article provides an author's view on a normative and legal content of the basis of criminal proceedings - access to the court and a binding nature of court decisions. It is emphasized that international human rights instruments and case-law of the European Court of Human Rights have adopted a distinction between the notion of access to a court and a fair trial as separate elements of the right to justice. At the same time, the current version of Part 1 of Art. 21 CPC Ukraine does not take into account this distinction and actually identifies access to justice with a fair trial, which is not fully consistent with the content of other general principles of criminal proceedings and does not quite accurately reflect the essence of access to justice. The authors support an expediency of using the term "access to a court" instead of "access to justice", taking into account it’s appliance for judicial and pre-trial proceedings. There is substantiated a necessity of establishing the requirement to ensure the right to access to court as a free opportunity for everyone to apply for judicial protection of their rights in the content of the relevant principles of criminal proceedings. It is also offered to consolidate such a significant procedural component of access to the court and the binding nature of a court decisions as ensuring real access to procedural acts adopted during criminal proceedings and relating to the rights and duties of a person, directly in the text of the current CPC of Ukraine.
Authors and Affiliations
Ruslan Stepaniuk, Daria Stepanyuk
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP628563
- DOI -
- Views 270
- Downloads 0
Comprehensive Analysis of Independent Regulatory Authorities in Ukraine, Portugal and Lithuania
This scientific article is aimed to explore independent regulatory authorities in Ukraine, their affiliation with the executive branch of government or a separate functioning. The author also addresses the problems of le...
Peculiarities of Compensation for Moral Damage in Unconventional Obligations
The scientific article deals with the definition of moral damage and the main forms of its manifestation. Also, the article examines the features of moral damage in unconventional liability, including the specifics of th...
До питання змішаної (подвійної) форми вини: наукові погляди / To the Issue of Double Form of Guilt: Scientific Views
The article analyzes the concept of double form of guilt in the theory of criminal law and judicial practice. A mixed (complex, double) form of guilt is called a different mental attitude of a person in the form of inten...
Баймуратов М.О., Гріненко О.О. Рішення Європейського суду з прав людини щодо дружнього врегулювання: проблеми теорії та практики / ECHR Decisions on Friendly Settlement against Ukraine: Problems of Theory and Practice
The issue of definitive features of the ECHR decisions on friendly settlement in cases against Ukraine is analyzed in the article, the aspects of such decisions` interpretation, translation, execution and implementation...
Executive Authority and Civil Society: Aspects of Interaction
The article explores issues of cooperation between executive authorities and civil society. Participation of nation or community in the management of public affairs, politics and state activities is defined as the criter...