Notes on a Few Issues in the Philosophy of Psychiatry
Journal Title: Mens Sana Monographs - Year 2009, Vol 7, Issue 1
Abstract
The first part called the [i]Preamble[/i] tackles: (a) the issues of silence and speech, and life and disease; (b) whether we need to know some or all of the truth, and how are exact scienceand philosophical reason related; (c) the phenomenon of Why, How, and What; (d) how are mind and brain related; (e) what is robust eclecticism, empirical/scientific enquiry, replicability/refutability, and the role of diagnosis and medical model in psychiatry; (f) bioethics and the four principles of beneÞ cence, non-malfeasance, autonomy, and justice; (g) the four concepts of disease, illness, sickness, and disorder; how confusion is confounded by these concepts but clarity is imperative if we want to make sense of these concepts; and how psychiatry is an interim medical discipline. The second part called [i]The Issues [/i]deals with: (a) the concepts of nature and nurture; the biological and the psychosocial; and psychiatric disease and brain pathophysiology;(b) biology, Freud and the reinvention of psychiatry; (c) critics of psychiatry, mind-bodyproblem and paradigm shifts in psychiatry; (d) the biological, the psychoanalytic, the psychosocial and the cognitive; (e) the issues of clarity, reductionism, and integration; (f)what are the fool-proof criteria, which are false leads, and what is the need for questioning assumptions in psychiatry. The third part is called [i]Psychiatric Disorder, Psychiatric Ethics, and Psychiatry Connected Disciplines. [/i]It includes topics like (a) psychiatric disorder, mental health, and mental phenomena; (b) issues in psychiatric ethics; (c) social psychiatry, liaisonpsychiatry, psychosomatic medicine, forensic psychiatry, and neuropsychiatry. The fourth part is called [i]Antipsychiatry, Blunting Creativity, etc.[/i] It includes topics like (a) antipsychiatry revisited; (b) basic arguments of antipsychiatry, Szasz, etc.; (c) psychiatricclassification and value judgment; (d) conformity, labeling, and blunting creativity. The fifth part is called [i]The Role of Philosophy, Religion, and Spirituality in Psychiatry.[/i] It includes topics like (a) relevance of philosophy to psychiatry; (b) psychiatry, religion, spirituality, and culture; (c) ancient Indian concepts and contemporary psychiatry; (d)Indian holism and Western reductionism; (e) science, humanism, and the nomothetic idiographicorientation. The last part, called [i]Final Goal[/i], talks of the need for a grand unified theory.The whole discussion is put in the form of refutable points.
Authors and Affiliations
Ajai Singh, Shakuntala Singh
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP84096
- DOI -
- Views 150
- Downloads 0
Biological Psychiatry, Research And Industry
In this section, we look at how the biological paradigm shift in psychiatry has been aided and abetted by industry for serving its own needs; which stymies other promising approaches; but which, nonetheless, can serve to...
The making of a physician
Medicine is a science, healing an art. The right mix of a scientist and artist is essential in a good physician. Clinical detachment is the balance between the scientist and the human. Good physicians are born; however,...
Dedication: Woman
Born a female, becoming a woman. At least sometimes, caught in the crossfire of sex and gender, of sexual dimorphism and gender inequality, of feminist activism and male chauvinism. ...................... Woman, t...
A look at CMAJ: A misty image indeed
The date: Feb 20, 2006. Medical publishing was rocked by the sudden dismissal of the Editor In Chief of the CMAJ (Canadian Medical Association Journal), John Hoey, and a Senior Deputy Editor Anne Mary Todkill. The Editor...
Questions That This Monograph Raises
What is the ideal combination of increased investment in biomedical research by sponsors with least conflict of interest in researchers? What should interested parties do to refurbish pharma's image? Is a voluntary mor...