On the Choice of Linear Regression Algorithms for Biological and Ecological Applications
Journal Title: Annual Research & Review in Biology - Year 2016, Vol 10, Issue 3
Abstract
Model II regression (i.e. minimizing residuals obliquely) is the adequate alternative to Model I regression by Ordinary Least Squares (i.e. minimizing residuals vertically) given the absence of well-established dependence relationships or x measured with error. Yet, it has no perfect solution. Determining the true slope from errors-in-the-variables models requires the errors in x and y estimated from higher order moments. However, their accurate estimation requires enormous data sets and thus they are not applicable to most ecological problems. The alternative Reduced Major Axis (RMA) is dependent on a strict set of assumptions, hardly met with real data, making it prone to bias, whereas Principal Components Analysis (PCA) becomes less reliable with decreasing correlations while x and y presenting approximate variances. We used artificial data (allowing for the determination of the true slope) to demonstrate when RMA or PCA should be preferred. Consequently, we propose using PCA whenever r2+s2x/s2y is higher than 1.5. Otherwise, we suggest generating artificial data manipulated to match the structure of the original, and to test which method provides closer estimates to the input true slope. We provide a user-friendly script to perform this task. We tested the use of RMA and PCA with real data about intraspecific and interspecific biomass-density relations in algae and seagrass, algae frond growth, crustacean and bird morphometry, sardine fisheries and social sciences data, commonly finding widely divergent slope estimates leading to severely biased parameter estimations and model applications. Their analyses support the suggested approach for method selection summarized above.
Authors and Affiliations
Vasco M. N. C. S. Vieira, Joel Creed, Ricardo A. Scrosati, Anabela Santos, Georg Dutschke, Francisco Leitão, Aschwin H. Engelen, Oscar R. Huanel, Marie-Laure Guillemin, Marcos Mateus, Ramiro Neves
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP351071
- DOI 10.9734/ARRB/2016/25219
- Views 101
- Downloads 0
Impact of Carbon Dioxide and Increasing Nitrogen Levels on Growth, Photosynthetic Capacity, Carbohydrates and Secondary Metabolites in Kacip Fatimah (Labisia pumila)
Aims: This study was designed to investigate how CO2 and nitrogen availability alters growth, leaf gas exchange, primary and secondary metabolites production (total phenolics and flavonoid) in three varieties of L. pumil...
An Intermetamorphic Larval Stage of a Mantis Shrimp and Its Contribution to the 'Missing-Element Problem' of Stomatopod Raptorial Appendages
In eumalacostracan crustaceans the thoracic appendages usually have seven elements along the main axis of the appendage. Mantis shrimps are an exception: their raptorial sub-chelate maxillipeds (anterior thoracopods) hav...
Evaluation of the Clastogenicity of SJG-136, A Novel Pyrrolobenzodiazepine DNA Interstrand Cross-linking Agent, in Comparison with Nitrogen Mustard (HN2)
Aims: SJG-136 is a new pyrrolobenzodiazepine used as an anticancer drug with high cytotoxicity against a panel of cancer cells and proved to produce interstrand crosslinks in the minor groove of DNA. Methodology: In thi...
Effects of Silymarin on Oxidative Stress Markers in Rats Treated with Magnesium Oxide Nanoparticles
This study investigated the protective and anti-oxidative effects of silymarin on rats treated with MgO NPs. Number of 32 male wistar rats were used in this experiment, assigned to four groups; one, the control group an...
Spatial Distribution of Pterocarpus erinaceus Poir. (Fabaceae) Natural Stands in the Sudanian and Sudano-Guinean Zones of West Africa: Gradient Distribution and Productivity Variation across the Five Ecological Zones of Togo
Aims: This study aims to analyze the structure of some populations and the natural regeneration potentials of Pterocarpus erinaceus Poir. According to the environmental conditions, taking into account the 5 ecological zo...