Orientalism and Muslim Historical Critical Methods
Journal Title: Journal of Islamic Thought and Civilization (JITC) - Year 2014, Vol 4, Issue 0
Abstract
Apart from the orientalists` ignorance, bias and grudges, there is a very basic academic reason which takes them away from the position that Muslims hold in the study of Islam and Islamic Civilization, even if they try hard to be objective in their studies. That reason, in its core, is epistemic. Muslims were forced to believe only in the truth. For that, they devised methods to determine the truthfulness of knowledge. In this article, I particularly discussed the methods with which they studied the authenticity of a transmitted knowledge; historicity. Two methods of transmission are discussed; Tawātur and Khabr al-Wāhid. What these concepts are and how they are helpful in determining the truthfulness of knowledge are explained. How tawātur provides absolute knowledge, while khabr al-wāhid does not. These methods are named as Muslim Historical Critical Methods for better understanding. Orientalists rejected many authentic contents of Islam because they were ignorant of these methods. Therefore, their rejections are sometime too absurd for Muslims to believe in the objectivity of their research.
Authors and Affiliations
Sajid Shahbaz Khan
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP489180
- DOI 10.32350/jitc.41.05
- Views 161
- Downloads 0
Problems and Possibilities in Reconciling Islam and Gender Equality Policies in Pakistan
The research focuses on the compatibility issues between the notion of ‘gender equality’ and the ‘religion Islam.’ This article investigates, if any, gender policy (s) build around the conciliation developed in the conte...
Crisis of Muslim civilization in modern times: Some insights from Ibn-e-Khaldun’s thoughts and ideas
No one would, probably, doubt that Muslim civilization is facing a serious crisis since the 18th century. It first resulted in political chaos and ultimately colonization of Muslim lands by Western powers. Later, Muslim...
An Examination of Causes of Delay in the Distribution of Estates in Ilorin and its Environs
In the last two decades or thereabout, Area Courts and indeed other courts with jurisdiction to hear and determine Muslim matters in Ilorin have been inundated with cases involving distribution of estate of deceased Musl...
Reformation: Religious, Political and Social Consequences for Western Society
Reformation was a theological movement in 16th century Europe to reform the Catholic Christianity. Luther, Calvin and Zwingli questioned the authority of dogma and supremacy of the pope in Rome. This led to the formation...
Philosophizing Tasawwuf: The Postmodern Cult of Sufism
The paper is a critical study of some relatively recent Western approaches to tasawwuf. These so-called post-structuralist approaches, the deconstructionist being chief among them, seem to extend the earlier orientalist...