Przekroczenie granic obrony koniecznej – w sprawie propozycji nowelizacji art. 25 Kodeksu karnego
Journal Title: Zeszyty Prawnicze Biura Analiz Sejmowych - Year 2018, Vol 57, Issue 1
Abstract
The author of the petition postulates the introduction of Article 25 para. 3a of the Criminal Code, in which the privilege of impunity for a person crossing the borders of necessary defense in a situation of defense against an unlawful, direct assault directed at legal rights set out in that regulation, would be guaranteed. It is concluded in the opinion that a more appropriate solution would be to link the non-subject to punishment of persons crossing the boundaries of the necessary defense with a more universal and capacious formula of “justifying the crossing of the limits of necessary defense by the circumstances accompanying the attack.” Thus the petition does not seem to be justified. The mere fact that a person crossing the boundaries of defense necessary would not be subject of the penalty only due to the fact that he/she acts in defense of certain legal rights, made in isolation from other important elements of the incident, reduces the assessment of his/her behavior and may lead to mandatory release from penalties in socially unacceptable cases.
Authors and Affiliations
Paweł Bachmat
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP385739
- DOI -
- Views 42
- Downloads 0
Opinia prawna w sprawie punktów doradztwa prawnego organizowanych w biurach poselskich
Providing legal advice in the deputy’s office is admissible, because stays with‑in the scope of the so-called field activities of Deputies. The author pays attention to the necessity of fulfilling the conditions of admis...
Ocena rządowego projektu nowelizacji ustawy o podatku od towarów i usług oraz ustawy – Ordynacja podatkowa
In the author’s opinion the proposed change in the way of identifying goods and services for VAT purposes, taking as a point of reference the coherence with the EU law, should be assessed positively. The consequence of t...
Opinia prawna na temat możliwości udzielenia pełnomocnictwa posłowi, przedstawicielowi wnioskodawców projektu ustawy, do reprezentowania rządu oraz Sejmu w postępowaniu notyfikacyjnym przed Komisją Europejską
The author of the opinion claims that the Marshal of the Sejm is unable to grant power of attorney to a Deputy, representing the sponsors of a bill, to represent the government and the Sejm in notification proceedings be...
Opinia prawna w sprawie przepisów regulaminu Sejmu dotyczących obniżenia uposażenia i diety parlamentarnej w kontekście najnowszego orzecznictwa Europejskiego Trybunału Praw Człowieka
The provisions of the Standing Orders of the Sejm concerning the reduction of Deputy’s salary or parliamentary per diem allowance (as a form of financial penalty) do not require any changes, as there is no need to adjust...
Opinia prawna dotycząca udzielania przez Prokuratora Krajowego (pierwszego zastępcę Prokuratora Generalnego) odpowiedzi na interpelacje i zapytania poselskie
The considerations concern the issue of legality of replies of National Prosecutor to interpellations and Deputies questions on matters related to activities of the prosecution. A reply made by the National Prosecutor is...