REFRAMING HETEROGENEITY AS AN INHERENT OUTCOME (NOT A PRESUMED TRAIT) OF GLOBALIZATION
Journal Title: Journal of Globalization Studies - Year 2015, Vol 6, Issue 1
Abstract
The contemporary study of globalization is a product of disparate scholarship across myriad disciplines. Given the eclectic nature of such cross-disciplinary pursuits, the vital labor of critically unpacking certain fundamental analytical concepts can too often be neglected. The treatment of heterogeneity – and manifestations of individual agency – across the global landscape presents a case in point. Juxtaposing the structural determinism of hegemonic global forces with the dynamic, creative impulses of local agency presents a familiar and long-standing riddle. While this global/local paradox may not have originated with the study of globalization, its enigmatic features are made especially salient via analyses of the contemporary global era. Those framing globalization as a multi-layered process of heterogeneous particularization provide especially compelling perspectives in this regard. It is argued here, however, that proponents of global heterogeneity have become mired in circular, tautological arguments. Our aim is to re-ground such theories with an analytical-conceptual framework in which the conditions for local heterogeneity (and agency) emerge from concrete social actions and are no longer inserted as a priori premises of the theory itself. The purpose of this paper is thus two-fold. First, we examine the failed reasoning that buttresses the prevailing heterogeneous interpretations of globalization. Second, we introduce an analytical-conceptual framework that results in rationale independent of a priori premises for resolving the global/local paradox and for positing heterogeneity as an inherent outcome – and not a mere feature (or presumed trait) – of the current era of globalization. To illustrate, we ap-ply this framework to an analysis of HIV/AIDS in Mozambique.
Authors and Affiliations
David Baronov
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP262999
- DOI -
- Views 109
- Downloads 0
STATUS OF INDIAN EDUCATION SYSTEM IN GLOBALISATION
Right from the well-planned and sound guru-shishya tradition (when a student while living in his teacher's house as Brahmachari with simple living and high thinking education) the education system has never remained free...
GEOPOLITICAL CONDITIONS OF INTERNATIONALISM, HUMAN RIGHTS AND WORLD LAW
International rule of law is not an alternative to geopolitics, but is successful only under specific geopolitical conditions. As historical sociologists in the tradition of Weber have documented, the state's existence h...
ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS IN HIGH INCOME COUNTRIES AND POLITICALLY AUTONOMOUS UNITS: RECENT ESTIMATED STOCKS BY COUNTRY AND UNIT
This paper estimates stocks of illegal immigrants currently residing in the high income world by country and politically autonomous unit (PAU). The estimates either come as such from sources or are computed here based on...
TOWARD COMPARATIVE GLOBALIZATIONS:GLOBALIZATION IN HISTORICAL RETROSPECTIVE AND WORLD-SYSTEM ANALYSIS
This introduction explains the background and underlying theoretical and substantive debates about globalization, world-systems analysis, and the ways to make comparisons among them. It provides information to introduce...
FISCAL COMPOSITION AND ECONOMIC GROWTH IN CENTRAL AMERICA UNDER GLOBAL ECONOMIC LIBERALIZATION
Current globalization trends are expected to impact the economy of the Cen-tral American nations through changes in the composition of fiscal budgets. This paper investigates the impact of changes in the composition of p...