Requirements for administrative court decisions: Polish and Ukrainian experience
Journal Title: Наукові записки Інституту законодавства Верховної Ради України - Year 2019, Vol 1, Issue 2
Abstract
The purpose of the article is illumination normatively legal regulations of requirements to the court decisions in the administrative legal proceeding of Ukraine and Poland. A scientific novelty consists in to comparatively legal study of institute of court decisions, which has inter-branch character, in the Ukrainian and Polish laws from the administrative legal proceeding. Research pre-condition was become by difficulties and lacks of judicial enforcement, related to quality of court decisions and order of their acceptance. Not correct exposition of positions of parts is noticed 1–3 articles of 242 Codes of the administrative legal proceeding of Ukraine. It is discovered that unlike the Ukrainian law, legality, validity and explained of court decisions of the Polish courts, does not have direct legislative regulation. Such requirements swim out from maintenance of legislative act. Fixing of explained is offered, as requirements to the court decision, in Code of the administrative legal proceeding of Ukraine: decision, accepted a court with aiming of reasons of his acceptance. Author opinion in relation to the general and excellent a sign of institute of court decisions in administrative cases, both in rich in content and norm setting aspects, and expedience of him is expressed normatively improvement. Conclusions. Sum up, that general principles and international standards and achievements of European practice are taken into account and observed the legislator of and Ukraine, and Poland. Polish approach is selected by acceptance of court decision in the administrative legal proceeding in the type of decision, sentence and decision (decision of the Higher administrative court of Poland). The general prospects of both countries are see approaching of the judicial system to consumer need judicial services, in particular, passing (development, improvement) of the legal proceeding to the electronic form, development of internal and external of communication strategy, in fact the use of electronic services in the legal proceeding is a modern public query in all states.
Authors and Affiliations
J. Moroz
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP548349
- DOI 10.32886/instzak.2019.02.07
- Views 80
- Downloads 0
Contradictions of the conceptual apparatus in the study of the pension system
The purpose of the article. The designation of elements of the pension system, as well as the logical connection between the basic concepts in the study of this system. Scientific novelty. The article deals with the sys...
Regulatory environment for the formation of the provision system of persons with disabilities in Ukraine
За умов сьогодення забезпечення прав осіб з інвалідністю є важливою метою нормативно-правового регулювання суспільних відносин, учасниками яких є особи з інвалідністю. При цьому відносини, пов’язані з соціально-економічн...
The Problem of Correlation Between the Notions «Constitutional Process» and «Constitutional Procedure».
The article is devoted to the problem of defining the notion of «constitutional process» through the study of its constituent elements and links with related notions, such as «constitutional procedure». The main theoreti...
Review on the textbook edited by Hrushko Viktor and Skulysh Yuliia «Pension system»
Review on the textbook edited by Hrushko Viktor and Skulysh Yuliia «Pension system» Актуальність наукового осмислення проблематики пенсійного забезпечення обумовлюється нагальною потребою розробки дієвих механізмів реалі...
Scope and structure of the shadow economy in the world and the causes of its development.
The article is devoted to the study of the scale of the shadow economy in Ukraine, the countries of the European Union and other foreign countries. The structure and causes of the growth of the shadow economy in the coun...