Supervaluationism and the timeless solution to the foreknowledge problem
Journal Title: Scientia et Fides - Year 2016, Vol 4, Issue 1
Abstract
If God knew I were going to write this paper, was I able to refrain from writing it this morning? One possible response to this question is that God's knowledge does not take place in time and therefore He does not properly fore-know. According to this response, God knows absolutely everything, it's just that He knows everything outside of time. The so-called timeless solution was one of the influential responses to the foreknowledge problem in classical Christian Theology. This solution, however, seemed to lose support in the recent debate. For example, Pike claims that "the doctrine of God's timelessness entered Christian Theology (only) because Platonic thought was stylish at the time" (Pike, 1970, 190) and Hasker (2001) catalogues this as one of the minor solutions to the problem. One possible source for this general attitude towards timelessness is the thought that the very idea of timelessness is incoherent. In this paper I argue that that the timeless solution to the foreknowledge problem is congenial with the supervaluationist theory of branching time and that this formal framework provides, in fact, a precise characterization of the timeless solution to the foreknowledge problem. The views presented in this paper are in line with those of Kretzmann and Stump (1981), Leftow (1991) and De Florio and Frigerio (2015).
Authors and Affiliations
Pablo Cobreros
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP195110
- DOI 10.12775/SetF.2016.015
- Views 89
- Downloads 0
On a productive dialogue between religion and science
Searching for common ground in philosophy, science and theology, it seems to us that it would be reasonable to maintain the position of realistic pragmatism that Charles Sanders Peirce had called pragmaticism. In the pra...
Racionalidad de la inducción como minimización entrópica
Rationality of induction as entropic minimization In favour of a fundamental aspect of the epistemology of Mariano Artigas –his commitment to the quest for truth on the part of the scientific theory– I argue about the r...
Los tratados médicos renacentistas en la gnoseología de Francisco Suárez
Renaissance medical treatises in the psychology of Francisco Suarez Spanish Renaissance physicians, especially Francis Valles, are a major source of inspiration for Suarez's commentary to De anima. This paper analyzes t...
El olvido de los presupuestos de la ciencia y de la filosofía
The neglect of the presuppositions of science and philosophy This paper is based on the suggestion of Professor Artigas in order to bring to light the epistemological and ontological assumptions of scientific activity,...
La crítica de Juan de santo Tomás del concepto suareciano de materia prima
The John of Saint Thomas' critique of the suarecian concept of the prime matter The figure of Juan Poinsot (Juan de Santo Tomás, Joannis a Santo Thoma) is inserted in the movement of return to a Thomism free of nominali...