The axiological influence of the decisions of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine on the legislation on public administration in the sphere of health protection
Journal Title: Науковий вісник Міжнародного гуманітарного університету. Серія: «Юриспруденція» - Year 2017, Vol 29, Issue 1
Abstract
The article analyzes three decisions, which are important for further improvement, including systematization, national legislation on public administration in the field of health care. The decision of 20 January 2012 in the case of the constitutional petition of the Zhashkivsky District Council of the Cherkassy Region concerning the official interpretation of the provisions of the first, second, and the second part of Article 32, parts two, three of Article 34 of the Constitution of Ukraine, although it is chronologically different has a general character in relation to the problem under consideration , while the Decision of October 30, 1997 in the case of K.G.Ustimenko has a special character – it pays a certain attention to information related to the state of health of an individual. It was found that when making the last decision, the Constitutional Court of Ukraine considered a conflict between two constitutional values, one of which is the protection of personal rights and freedoms, and the other in an attempt to ensure state and public security by removing mentally ill persons from employment to public authorities. The Constitutional Court of Ukraine in this conflict favored such a constitutional value as the priority of human rights and freedoms to the interests of the state. It should be noted that the development of legislation on public administration in the healthcare sector has not yet been resolved. This is evidenced by the fact that already in 2016 the Constitutional Court of Ukraine returns to one of its aspects. Namely: in the case of judicial control of the hospitalization of incapacitated persons in a psychiatric institution, the court resolved a conflict of constitutional values, similar to that which was posed in the case of K.G. Ustimenko.
Authors and Affiliations
Г. М. Сарибаєва
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP467467
- DOI -
- Views 81
- Downloads 0
Areas of improvement of legal regulation of administrative relations in the field of educational services
The article based on an analysis of scientific views of scholars and laws of Ukraine the main directions of improvement of legal regulation of administrative relations in the field of education. Proved that sex problems...
Problem of defining the goals and objectives of commercial courts in Ukraine
In the article the purpose and objectives of commercial courts in Ukraine in conditions of modernity. We consider the concept of objective economic courts and the necessity of delimitation of tasks. Conducted performance...
Legal characterization of tourist services
The article is devoted to the definition of a place of tourist services in the system of service kinds, the establishment of general and specific characteristics of tourism services, as well as the characterization of en...
The application by the party of protection of the legal conclusions of the European Court of Human Rights while appealing against the definition of an inquest judge on the choice of a preventive measure
The article is devoted to the investigation of the problem of practical application by the defense side during the pre – trial inquiry of the ECHR’s practice as a source of criminal procedural law of Ukraine.
Theoretical and legal analysis of judicial practice of high specialized courts in Ukraine as a source of law
The results of the research of the signs of judicial acts as well as the possibilities of the confession of the practice of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine, Supreme Court of Ukraine and European Court of Human Rights...