The Implementation of Indonesia's Health Law Regulation No. 17 of 2023: A Legal-Political Analysis of Centralization and Authoritarian Tendencies
Journal Title: International Journal of Social Science And Human Research - Year 2025, Vol 8, Issue 04
Abstract
The centralization of authority in the central government is perceived as weakening regional autonomy and local policy diversity. The legislative process of this law has also been criticized for lacking substantial involvement from civil society and professional organizations. Meanwhile, the digitalization of health data, although improving efficiency, poses risks of state data misuse. This policy raises concerns regarding government accountability, particularly due to the weak mechanisms for public oversight and evaluation.This study examines the implementation of Law Number 17 of 2023 on Health through a legal-political analysis, particularly its tendency towards an authoritarian political configuration. Drafted in response to health challenges during the COVID-19 pandemic, this law aims to reform the national health system with a more centralized approach. However, characteristics such as power centralization, minimal public participation, strict monitoring through health data digitalization, and repressive policies toward medical professionals indicate a reduction in democratic principles in the health sector's governance. Through a progressive legal perspective, this paper emphasizes the importance of applying the principles of justice, utility, and legal certainty in health policies. The Health Law should promote inclusivity, transparency, and active participation from the public and medical professionals. The author recommends decentralizing health policies, strengthening data protection, revising regulations to reduce authoritarian characteristics, and prioritizing deliberative democracy in health reforms.
Authors and Affiliations
Stella Hita Arawinda, Fifiana Wisnaeni
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP764798
- DOI 10.47191/ijsshr/v8-i4-16
- Views 3
- Downloads 0
Political Review of the 2009 Number 32 Law on Environmental Protection and Management
The 2009 payload or bill change policy on environmental protection and management was directed to provide both revision and new arrangements to address issues related to the development of innovation in policy, internati...
Big Tech, Social Media, and American Foreign Policy: The Role of Elon Musk and Donald Trump in Shaping Global Politics
This paper examines the growing influence of Big Tech companies and social media platforms on American foreign policy, with a particular focus on the roles played by Elon Musk and Donald Trump. The rise of social media a...
Self-regulation among state university students in an online learning environment
A state university in the Philippines participated in the resumption of limited face-to-face classes after two years of closure due to the COVID-19 pandemic, thereby allowing for online learning. This study assessed the...
Factors That Influence Drug Addiction: An Analysis of Tokhang Surrenderees Institution-Based Rehabilitation
This is a descriptive research which aimed to determine the factors influencing drug addiction extending the Dislocation Theory of Addiction. Selected variables from this theory were operationalized through indicators wh...
Law Reform in the Juvenile Criminal Justice System in Indonesia
The true law is always in the process of becoming (law making), this also happens in the juvenile justice system in Indonesia, which is always in the process of becoming. This is what makes it important to reform the juv...