W sprawie budownictwa we wczesnośredniowiecznym Wolinie
Journal Title: Materiały Zachodniopomorskie - Year 2015, Vol 0, Issue
Abstract
The article is a polemical response to Błażej Stanisławski’s (2011) comments on early medieval construction in Wolin published in Volume VI/VII of ‘Materiały Zachodniopomorskie’. I do not agree with the dating of the oldest log construction and wattle-and-daub construction buildings. I also question the terminology used by this researcher, Furthermore, I believe there is some exaggerated interpretation of finds, unreliable reconstructions of post-and-beam buildings, erroneous selection of illustrations for the presented issues and a lack of examples as well as references supporting the theory of Frisian analogies of the post-and-beam construction. In the section on palisade construction structures I polemicize B. Stanisławski on Wolin long houses, we agree that the presence of the palisade construction buildings in Wolin is not synonymous with the presence of Scandinavian settlers. The vertical-post log construction was, in my opinion, presented too briefly based on only one building from trench 6 in Wolin’s Old Town. In summary, I conclude that the work by B. Stanisławski has many shortcomings, the reinterpretations of discoveries of older researchers are unconvincing and the presented documentation is inaccurate.
Authors and Affiliations
Eugeniusz Cnotliwy
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP227141
- DOI -
- Views 46
- Downloads 0
Od wzlotów ducha po światła rozumu. Grafika francuska ze zbiorów Muzeum Narodowego w Szczecinie oraz Muzeum Narodowego w Warszawie. Wystawa czasowa
Temporary exhibition of French Graphics hosted by the National Muzeum in Szczecin;
„Importowane” naczynia typu Tornow i Gross Raden na stanowiskach 2 i 2a w Cedyni, woj. zachodniopomorskie
The work concerns the finds of early medieval vessels of Tornow and Gross Raden type in cemeteries in Cedynia - the cremation (site 2) and the inhumation one (site 2a), which are the products of foreign origins, evidenci...
Die archäologischen Arbeiten in Świelubie 2015–2016 Excavations at Świelubie in 2015–2016 Badania archeologiczne w Świelubiu w latach 2015–2016
During the second season of excavations at Świelubie, Dygowo commune, exploration of stratification in trenches from 2015 was finished. Several small trial trenches were started. Discovered objects indicate that the sett...
Trzebiatów – spotkania pomorskie 2014, red. Janina Kochanowska, Trzebiatów 2015, ISBN 978-83-7591-461-0
Review of a book entitled Nordic Middle Ages – Artefacts, Landscapes and Society. Essays in Honour of Ingvild Øye on her 70th Birthday.
Konwent cysterek w Koszalinie. Część 1. Zarys dziejów
Cistercian nuns were brought to Koszalin in the years 1277–1278. Their abbey was dedicated to the Blessed Virgin Mary. The source material for the history of Koszalin convent reflects its complex structure. It enables us...