What Is It All About in the Interview? An Attempt to Interpret the Memories About the Jews as Narratives of Identity
Journal Title: PRZEGLĄD SOCJOLOGII JAKOŚCIOWEJ - Year 2015, Vol 11, Issue 4
Abstract
The article presents a method of interpreting in-depth interviews regarding the ways in which non-Jewish Poles remember Jews. The intention of the suggested method is to find a new perspective that would be complementary to the two most important ones that can be found in the Polish research on this subject: the ethnographic approach and the perspective inspired by psychoanalysis. The main assumption of the presented method is that an interview is not a recollection of the past but a narrative of identity in which the past is (re)constructed according to the imperatives of the present in which the interview is conducted, and the Jews serve to an interviewee only as a frame of reference for his/her constructs of identity. It is further assumed that narratives of identity are constructed along four main dimensions: sacrum, death, sex, and power/violence, each with its own cultural semantics and binary code that is used to separate practices and beliefs that characterize “Us” from those we attribute to “Them.” These codes, together with stories about “Us” and “Them,” make the warp and weft of the narrative identity represented in the interview, which corresponds to Clifford Geertz’s idea of culture as the webs of significance we have spun and in which we are entangled. Then, a single interview has been selected and interpreted to show how the interviewee organizes his stories about Jews in different semantics and codes to keep his narrative of identity consistent.
Authors and Affiliations
Sławomir Kapralski
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP164252
- DOI -
- Views 175
- Downloads 0
Action, Expertise, Knowledge. On Works of Harry Collins
The review essay discusses books of Harry Collins and co-authors (“trilogy of expertise”). The discussed works are attempts to sort out theoretical outcomes from the ethnographic studies done within Science and Technolog...
Corpus Linguistics Techniques Used for Critical Discourse Analysis. An overview
The paper aims to present corpus methods most commonly used in Critical Discourse Analysis (CDA). The issues of corpus design for CDA will be discussed and methods frequently used in such analysis will be presented: freq...
Wizualna teoria ugruntowana. Podstawowe zasady i procedury
W artykule przedstawiam podstawowe procedury i pojęcia metodologii teorii ugruntowanej, w której używa się danych wizualnych. Metodologię tę nazywamy wizualną teorią ugruntowaną. Dane wizualne są tu używane, by konstr...
Meandry dialogu. Polacy i Żydzi w dyskursie prasowym międzywojennego Białegostoku
Niniejszy artykuł przedstawia próbę zastosowania pojęcia dyskursu w badaniu zjawiska etniczności. Głównymi inspiracjami teoretycznymi były prace związane z dwoma nurtami krytycznej analizy dyskursu: szkołą wiedeńską (R....
Zjawisko „fotografii fotografii”, czyli interpretacja zdjęć, które komentują same siebie
W niniejszym artykule krytyczna analiza fotografii Thomasa Strutha - zawarta w części pierwszej - staje się pretekstem do socjologicznej interpretacji specyficznego sposobu fotografowania. Tematem rozważanych zdjęć staje...