When a Market Runs a Hierarchy: Retrenchment of Bureaucratic Practices in Lithuanian Uniformed Services / Kai rinka valdo hierarchijas: biurokratijos įsitvirtinimas Lietuvos statutinėje tarnyboje
Journal Title: Socialiniai tyrimai - Year 2018, Vol 41, Issue 1
Abstract
Some public administration literature that focuses on public administration reform indulges in constructing grand narrative theories such as New Public Management (NPM), or New Governance (NG). The most recent such theory that has been gaining attention over the past decade is the Neo Weberian State (NWS). The content of the theory with regard to its practical implication when it comes to reform is still unsettled. However, one key assumption behind the NWS is that reforms should be handled with care, as they may undermine the very institutions that have brought Western societies to the levels of their development they are in now. NPM’s drive to increase efficiency, and NG’s – democracy from the point of view of NWS is impossible if reforms deconstruct institutions that ensure the protection of the public interest and rule of law. NWS’s critique of post-communist reform efforts in the new eastern EU member-states is a case in point suggesting that leapfrogging the construction of a professional bureaucracy is ill-advised and does not lead to politically desired outcomes. In this paper we aim to evaluate which path of reform may lead to the best outcomes in a particular area of the public service – two non-military uniformed services of Lithuania – customs and penitentiary. These services have to a large degree avoided sweeping reforms throughout the independence period, in both cases – a soviet institutional legacy is also a factor. Both Customs and the Penitentiary service are suffering from multiple corruption scandals and very low public trust levels. These services are continuously in the crosshairs of reform, but few have been clearly articulated, even less so – implemented. Applying NPM to uniformed services, due to the nature of their functions was complicated, so as reforms in the 1990s and 2000s went along in the other sectors, policy-makers have largely left uniformed to their own devices, and this has led to retrenchment of the bureaucratic principles as would historical institutionalisms theory predict. We suggest that NPM-oriented governance avoids intervention in areas where NPM principles are hard to apply, leaving such areas without proper attention to continue down undesirable development paths. When the deconstruction of a hierarchy appears impossible, higher order governance needs to remain modelled as hierarchy as well. NWS in this case does offer a management modernization agenda, which could keep state institutions in step with social, technological, and economic developments.
Authors and Affiliations
Svajūnė Ungurytė- Ragauskienė, Mantas Bileišis
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP327789
- DOI -
- Views 61
- Downloads 0
Tourism Development in the Municipalities in Eastern Aukštaitija Region Turizmo plėtros sąlygos Rytų Aukštaitijos regiono savivaldybėse
The authors of the article discuss tourism development conditions in the municipalities in Eastern Aukštaitija region. Scientific problem: tourism development trends at local, municipality, level have not been sufficient...
Švietimo įstaigų vadovų kompetencijų vertinimo kaita Lietuvoje / Changing Assessment of the Educational Institution Manager’s Competencies in Lithuania
Education is one of the key areas in the development of a democratic state. Educational institutions and organizations are keen on innovations, therefore, certain public administration initiatives are often primarily and...
Content Marketing Elements for Search Advertising Turinio marketingo elementų taikymas paieškos sistemose esančiose reklamose
The author analyzes the possibility of using content marketing elements for search advertising from marketing experts and searchers’ perspective. The first part of the paper deals with the theoretical insights into the c...
Effect of the Common Agricultural Policy on Agriculture and the Increasing Role of Nongovernmental Organisations / Auswirkungen der Gemeinsamen Agrarpolitik auf die Landwirtschaft und die zunehmende Rolle nichtstaatlicher Organisationen
The Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) has considerably contributed to changes in the rural environment of Latvia after its accession to the European Union (EU). The accession provided new opportunities and considerable fi...
Į sekėją orientuota lyderystė ir emocijos: tarpdisciplininė perspektyva Follower-Centric Leadership and Emotions: an Interdisciplinary Perspective
In leadership, a follower-centric approach, that emphasizes the importance of the follower in the leadership process presenting one of the latest approaches in leadership research, is considered to be one of the fields t...