Z powrotem do Arystotelesowskiej koncepcji znaczenia

Journal Title: Przegląd Tomistyczny - Year 2016, Vol 0, Issue

Abstract

This paper presents a new reading of Aristotle's theory of meaning. Its starting point is a claim made in a seminal paper by T. Irwin that Aristotle's notion of signification (semainein) is not the same as the modern concept of meaning. This claim has been challenged by some modern scholars (D. Charles, C. Shields), however, no conclusive arguments against it have been shown. The paper argues against Irwin's claim by pointing to two features of Aristotle's theory: first, it shows that what is signified by words in Aristotle's theory are "things" (pragmata) and that one particular sort of pragmata are universals; second, it shows that Aristotle's interest in signification is rooted in his interest in the actual linguistic practice of the average speaker of language.

Authors and Affiliations

Tomasz Tiuryn

Keywords

Related Articles

Wykłady wstępne (principia) filozofii i teologii ze szkół dominikanów wrocławskich na przykładzie tekstów z rękopisu I Q 386 Biblioteki Uniwersyteckiej we Wrocławiu

The manuscript I Q 386 from the University Library in Wrocław is a typical example of a codex of a Dominican scholar from the mid-15th century. It was copied out in the 1440’s and belonged to Maciej Hayn, a friar of the...

Prolegomena to an Edition of Albert's "Topics"

Albert’s monumental paraphrase on the Topics remains terra incognita for scholars in medieval philosophy. Before its importance can be truly assessed we need a critical edition of this text. The present article offers so...

Profesor Zofia Włodek (1925-2018). Wspomnienie

Wspomnienie o prof. Zofii Włodek

Puncta ex commentario Nicolai Tempelfeld de Brzeg in „Parva Naturaliaˮ: Editio Critica

Codex BJ 1946, held in the Jagiellonian Library of Krakow, is an important source for studies on teaching in Krakow in the 15th century. The main part of its content is the so-called puncta which belong to a peculiar gen...

Martyrdom and Soteriology in 2 Maccabees 7. The Closest Biblical Parallel with the Sayings of Jesus in His Last Supper

The aim of this paper is to show that there is no closer parallel in the whole Bible of the sayings of Jesus on bread and wine in the Last Supper according to the Synoptic gospels and Paul than 2 Macc 7:37-38. In order t...

Download PDF file
  • EP ID EP192027
  • DOI -
  • Views 87
  • Downloads 0

How To Cite

Tomasz Tiuryn (2016). Z powrotem do Arystotelesowskiej koncepcji znaczenia. Przegląd Tomistyczny, 0(), 347-408. https://europub.co.uk./articles/-A-192027