Effect of hand cooling on body temperature, cardiovascular and perceptual responses during recumbent cycling in a hot environment
Journal Title: Journal of Science and Cycling - Year 2014, Vol 3, Issue 2
Abstract
Exercise in hot environments increases body temperature and challenges the function of cardiovascular, metabolic and thermoregulatory systems. Elevated body temperature as a consequence of prolonged and/or intense exercise impairs athletic performance and increases the risk of heat illness and serious medical conditions. Pre-exercise cooling techniques have been used to lower body temperature and increase heat storage capacity during exercise. Head, neck and wrist cooling have also been employed to reduce physiological strain in hot environments. Although the majority of these methods have proven useful, some are impractical for use during exercise when heat strain is most pronounced. Hand cooling during exercise has the potential to alleviate these impracticalities and attenuate increases in body temperature due to the hands large surface to mass ratio, low metabolic heat production, large blood supply and rapid cooling rates. Reductions in body temperature after bouts of exercise and improvements in exercise performance have been observed using various hand cooling protocols. However, the effectiveness of hand cooling during exercise in a hot environment and the mechanisms of action are unclear. The purpose of the study was to quantify physiological and perceptual responses to hand immersion in water during recumbent cycling in a hot environment. In a randomised control design 7 well-trained males (body mass 79.8 s 6.3 kg; stature 182 s 5 cm; age 23 s 3 years; recumbent cycling V ̇O2peak 41 s 5 ml•kg-1•min-1) who were naïve to the study aims provided informed consent to participate in 3 trials. Participants immersed their hands in 8, 14 and 34°C water whilst cycling at an intensity (W) equivalent to 50% V ̇O2peak for 60 min in an environmental chamber maintained at 35°C 50% relative humidity. Intestinal and 4-site mean skin temperature and heart rate were monitored continuously and mean-averaged over 5 minute intervals. Rating of perceived exertion and thermal strain were assessed every 5 minutes. Data was assessed for normality and homogeneity of variance. The likelihood (% chance) of between group differences was assessed using a magnitude-based approach, Cohen's standardised difference score (d = 0.20 small, 0.5 moderate and 0.8 large effect) and 90% confidence intervals for [d]. Change in intestinal temperature was likely (84%) less in 8°C; 0.43 s 0.16°C versus 34°C; 0.55 s 0.16°C after 15 min; d = 0.73 [-0.19 to 1.65] and very likely (98%) less in 8°C; 0.78 s 0.28°C versus 34°C; 1.22 s 0.16°C after 40 min d = 1.36 [0.47 to 2.25]. Change in mean skin temperature was likely (87%) less in 8°C; -0.05 s 0.39°C versus 34°C; 0.31 s 0.46°C; d = 0.81 [0.09 to 1.71] after 5 min, very likely (98%) less after 15 min; -0.09 s 0.72°C versus 0.77 s 0.30°C; d = 1.24 [0.45 to 2.03] and onwards to cessation of exercise. Percentage of peak heart rate was likely (94%) lower in 8°C; 87 s 4% versus 34°C; 90 s 5% from 25 min onwards; d = 0.69 [0.18 to 1.20]. After 5 min of exercise rating of perceived exertion was likely (77%) lower in 8°C; 12.6 s 1.0 versus 34°C 13.4 s 1.7; d = 0.61 [-0.36 to 1.57] but was likely similar from 25 min onwards. Perception of thermal strain was likely (92%) lower in 8°C; 6.5 s 0.5 versus 34°C; 7.2 s 0.4 after 5 min exercise; d = 0.81 [0.09 to 1.71] and was almost certainly (>99%) lower; 7.3 s 0.7 versus 8.0 s 0.7 for the remainder of the trial; d = 1.21 [0.65 to 1.77]. Similar beneficial effects were observed for 14°C versus 34°C immersion but the magnitude of the effects was smaller than 8°C immersion. Small-to-moderate differences were observed between 8°C and 14°C immersion. The findings suggest that hand cooling during fixed moderate-intensity cycling in a hot environment has the potential to alleviate increases in body temperature, cardiovascular demand and perceptions of exertion and thermal strain. Greatest effects were observed when the hands were immersed in 8°C water compared with 14°C. Augmented heat loss at the palm-water surface might enable cooler blood to return to core and shell regions; increasing the thermal gradient between active tissue and blood thus improving internal heat transfer, maintaining a wide core to skin temperature gradient and reducing heat storage. Limiting the increase in body temperature might have lowered cardiovascular demands by reducing the requirement for cutaneous vasodilation thus lowering physiological strain. These combined effects are manifested in lowered perceptions of exertion and thermal strain. The findings from this study suggest that endurance exercise in hot environments might be improved by hand cooling and future research should investigate its effectiveness during cycling and running performance.
Authors and Affiliations
AD Ruddock| Centre for Sport and Exercise Science, Sheffield Hallam University, United Kingdom.Department of Sport, Sheffield Hallam University, United Kingdom, K Chatziopoulos| Department of Sport, Sheffield Hallam University, United Kingdom, T Parkington| Department of Sport, Sheffield Hallam University, United Kingdom, GA Tew| Department of Health Sciences, University of York, United Kingdom, A Purvis| Department of Sport, Sheffield Hallam University, United Kingdom
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP2872
- DOI -
- Views 391
- Downloads 20
Relationship between leg length and trunk orientation in cycling
Background: Rider position for a time trial will depend on several variables, including aerodynamics and sporting regulations set by the international governing body of cycling, the Union Cycliste Internationale (UCI). A...
Wearable multi-sensor system for embedded body position and motion analysis during cycling
Purpose: The purpose of this study was to validate the AREM system in laboratory conditions. AREM is an embedded electronic system for motion tracking and movement analysis, based on Micro Electro Mechanical Systems (MEM...
Effect of deceptively aggressive bike pacing on sprint-distance triathlon performance
Introduction: Whilst aggressive bike pacing has been found to impair subsequent run performance during triathlon, this strategy appears to enhance total cycle-run time over the sprint-distance format (Suriano & Bishop, 2...
The Body & the Bike: A Kinetic Chain analysis of Cycling Overuse Injury
Physiotherapists, osteopaths, doctors, bike-fitters and other cycling injury managers, are perfectly placed to help the ever-growing cycling community to become better riders as well as to prevent pain and injury. Whilst...
Reliability and Construct Validity of the Malay Version of the Cyclist Motivation Instrument (CMI)
With the increase interest in cycling, there is a need to understand what motivate cyclist to cycle. The Cyclist Motivation Instrument (CMI) has been shown to be a valid and reliable instrument to measure the motivation...