The Russian Jewish Question, Asked and Answered. Virtual Polemics Between Moisei Berlin and Yakov Brafman in the 1860s
Journal Title: Wrocławski Przegląd Teologiczny - Year 2018, Vol 0, Issue 1
Abstract
In the first half of the nineteenth century, Russian authorities had very limited knowledge of their Jewish subjects. The government relied more on its enlightened perceptions of the Jews and Judaism than on empirical observation. This situation changed radically in the 1860s, when at the onset of the Great Reforms era the government sought full and veritable information about all imperial subjects, including Jews, to facilitate the efficient policymaking by framing and answering Russian Jewish question. As a result, Russian language studies—written by Jews, Russian Christians, and Jewish converts to Christianity—on Judaism, Jewish history, society and culture started to appear. The article focuses on two such studies: Moisei Berlin's Essay on the Ethnography of the Jewish Population in Russia (1861) and Yakov Brafman's Book of Kahal (1869). Virtual polemics between Berlin and Brafman highlights fundamental differences between Russian studies of Judaism and Jewish life and classical Western European Christian Hebraism, namely, Russian scholars’ general lack of interest to the Talmud and to its alleged anti-Christian thrust, and almost exclusive focus on Jewish communal, social, and political institutes—kahal, chavurot (voluntary societies), beit din (rabbinical court) and others—and on their alleged anti-government nature.
Authors and Affiliations
Vassili Schedrin
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP423649
- DOI -
- Views 92
- Downloads 0
Zarys dziejów Kościoła katolickiego na ziemi głubczyckiej od średniowiecza do 1945 roku
Głubczyce area covers southern part of Opole Voivodship. It is bordered with the Czech Republic in the south and west. From 1038 or 1039 this ter- ritory was taken away from Poland and since then it belonged to the Czech...
Międzypokoleniowy przekaz wartości w rodzinie
The modern family experiences various crisis situations. These situations result from micro-sociological conditions such as: unemployment, lack of ac- comodation, economic poverty, mechanisms of the free market, inpourin...
Kamień, o który wszyscy się potykają (Mt 16, 23)
The article deals with the verse Matt. 16:23 in which Jesus addresses Peter in the following way: “Get thee behind me, Satan: thou art an offence unto me: for thou savourest not the things that be of God, but those that...
Bóg sprawiedliwości i Bóg miłosierdzia w świetle Wj 33, 19 i Wj 34, 6-7
Undertaking the theme of justice and charity of God, the author wants to show that these „attributes” of God do not exclude each other mutually. They mutually complete each other and are inseparably and existentially...
„I nie bądź niewierzącym”: żydowskie rozumienie uzasadnionej wiary
In the paper, the question of faith in Jesus is analyzed from the Jewish perspective. The concept of faith and trust is present in the Old Testament books, in the Qumran documents from the times of Jesus, and in Talmud t...