Засада змагальності кримінального судочинства у світлі рішень Європейського суду з прав людини / The Principle of the Comparative Criminal Judgment in the Light of the European Court of Human Rights
Journal Title: Журнал східноєвропейського права - Year 2017, Vol 41, Issue 41
Abstract
The priority trend of modern criminal-procedural reform in Ukraine is the need to bring criminal procedural legislation in line with European standards and norms. The European Court of Human Rights plays an important role in this direction. The European Court has repeatedly drawn attention to the requirement for criminal proceedings to be conducted in a manner consistent with the competition and equality of procedural rights of the parties. The legislator has done enormous work in this direction, but despite such a volume of work, an analysis of the judgments of the European Court of Human Rights shows that a large number of declarative provisions do not allow to fully provide a competitive model of legal proceedings in Ukraine, confirming why there are a large number of appeals to European court for protection. The article deals with the main problems that arise in the process of realization of the basis of competition in criminal proceedings and brought to attention by the European Court of Human Rights. Considerable attention is paid to the definition of competition, the lack of procedural equality of the parties, as well as other elements of competition. In order to eliminate these problems, the analysis and generalization of the decisions of the European Court of Human Rights concerning this issue have been analyzed.
Authors and Affiliations
Mykhailo Buhrym
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP624349
- DOI -
- Views 199
- Downloads 0
Нормативно-правовий зміст доступу до суду та обов’язковості судових рішень як засади кримінального провадження / Normative and Legal Content of Access to Court and a Binding Nature of a Court Decisions as Principles of Criminal Proceedings
The article provides an author's view on a normative and legal content of the basis of criminal proceedings - access to the court and a binding nature of court decisions. It is emphasized that international human rights...
Адміністративно-правове регулювання волонтерської діяльності в Україні / Аdministrative and Legal Regulation of Volunteer Activity in Ukraine
The issue of legal regulation of volunteer activity in Ukraine is gaining an importance, as well as the definition of the legal status of a volunteer, the integration into national legislation of international standards...
Застосування домашнього арешту як запобіжного заходу кримінального провадження / Application of Domestic Arrest as a Preventive Measure of Criminal Proceedings
The article deals with the institution of domestic arrest as a preventive measure in the criminal process. On the basis of doctrinal positions, the essence and main features of domestic arrest were disclosed. Home arrest...
Ратифікація Стамбульської Конвенції як спосіб утвердження гендерної рівності в суспільстві: проблеми українського законодавства / Ratification of Istanbul Convention as a Way of Affirmation of Gender Equality in Society: Problems of Ukrainian Legislation
This article is devoted to the problem of woman rights, gender equality and gender discrimination in society. The author affirms that the disparity between women and men is a consequence of some historical processes, tra...
Щодо деяких аспектів протидії організованій злочинності підрозділами кримінальної поліції України / On Counteraction to Organized Crime by Subdivisions of Criminal Police of Ukraine
The problematic aspects of the counteraction to the organized crime by the subdivisions of criminal police of Ukraine are reviewed and analysis of the legal provisions for the operational activities of separate operative...